My 'broker' FXChoice wants a 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' to release funds. Is this a new scam tactic?

asked 27d ago17 views350 answers
0

Hey everyone,

i'm really losing hope here. i got involved with this broker, FXChoice, last year after seeing some really flashy ads about high returns on crypto CFDs. stupid of me, i know. i started with a small amount, then they pressured me to put in more, saying i needed a bigger 'capital base' to really see the profits. i ended up putting in a significant chunk of my savings, like, low five figures USD.

Now i'm trying to withdraw, and it's been a nightmare. first, they ignored my requests, then they told me i needed to pay a 'tax clearance fee', which i questioned. now they're saying there's a 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' that needs to be paid before any withdrawal can be processed, to 'balance the books' for their regulators. they even sent me what looked like a professional invoice. my gut is screaming this is another trick to get more money out of me. this is stressing me out so much, i can't sleep. has anyone encountered this specific fee from FXChoice or another unregulated broker? what are my options? I'm in Singapore so i'm not sure if the MAS can even help with offshore brokers.

Mentioned in this discussion
FXChoice· scamMAS· trusted

350 Answers

37

Oh goodness, another one of these 'fees'. It's absolutely a scam, Hao. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is just another made-up term. These unregulated brokers, especially ones like FXChoice which the FCA has flagged multiple times, are notorious for inventing endless excuses to extract more money from victims. They prey on the hope that if you just pay *one more fee*, you'll get your money back. But it never happens. The money just vanishes.

Your best bet now is to gather all your evidence: bank statements showing deposits, all communications with them, their website screenshots, any 'invoices' they sent. In Germany, I'd suggest contacting BaFin, but for Singapore, approaching MAS is definitely worthwhile, even for offshore brokers, as they might have intelligence to share with international bodies or add them to their investor alert list. Don't send them another cent. That's the most crucial step.

Lina Neumann · Munich, Germanyanswered 27d ago
47

Ugh, this is infuriating to read because it's so predictable. Been there, done that, got the t-shirt, lost the money. I had a similar situation with an unregulated crypto platform, not FXChoice, but the pattern is identical. First, a 'verification fee,' then a 'blockchain transaction tax,' then a 'network congestion fee.' I paid a few, thinking ok, this is the last one. It never was. I lost close to $15,000 trying to 'unlock' my phantom profits.

They actually became more aggressive *after* I paid some of these fees, thinking I was susceptible. It wrecked me financially and emotionally. The moment you see these bizarre fees, especially after initial withdrawal requests are pending for a while, just know you're in a recovery scam. Stop all communication, block them. It sucks, but paying more won't magically make your original money appear.

Noah Bouchard · Montreal, Canadaanswered 27d ago
22

Damn, Hao, that's rough. Sounds exactly like what happened to me with a different dodgy broker back in '22. They hit me with a 'liquidity provider commission fee' after I supposedly 'earned' a huge amount. I was so desperate, I almost paid it. My cousin, who works in banking, told me straight up it was bollocks.

He explained that legit brokers don't ask you for fees to withdraw *your own profits*. They usually take their cut from spreads, commissions on trades, or maybe a small monthly inactivity fee, but never these weird 'reconciliation' or 'tax' fees *after* you've tried to withdraw. You're dealing with criminals, my friend. Don't pay them anything else. I lost about R40k that way, never got a cent back. It stings, but throwing more good money after bad won't help.

Joshua du Plessis · East London, South Africaanswered 27d ago
18

Look, I'm not gonna sugarcoat it. If they're asking for a 'profit and loss reconciliation fee,' it just screams scam. Think about it: a legitimate financial institution reconciles its own books. They don't make *you* pay for it, especially not as a prerequisite to get *your* money.

This is a classic trap to exploit your desperation. They know you want your initial investment, plus what you think are profits, so they invent these charges, hoping you'll pay them just to see your money. It's a psychological game. The moment they asked for a 'tax clearance fee,' that was your major red flag, a neon sign pointing to fraud. Any broker asking for *additional* upfront fees to release funds is trying to fleece you. Period.

Ethan du Plessis · Durban, South Africaanswered 27d ago
12

Honestly, the moment you mentioned 'FXChoice' and 'unregulated broker' in the same sentence, my alarm bells went off. I've heard too many stories. This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds like something someone just made up on the spot, you know? Like, what even is that? It's not a standard fee in any legitimate finance operation I've ever heard of.

They're playing you. They'll keep coming up with new fees until you either run out of money or realize you're being scammed. I wouldn't pay another dirham. Your best bet is to report everything to your bank and perhaps MAS, as others suggested. Sometimes, strong public warnings from regulators help prevent others from falling into the same trap, even if they can't directly help with recovering funds from offshore entities.

Layla Al Falasi · Sharjah, UAEanswered 27d ago
40

Hao, what you've described is a classic 'advance fee fraud' within the context of an unregulated brokerage scam. These fraudsters create a sense of urgency and invent complex-sounding financial terms to justify their demands for more money. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is completely made up. Legitimate brokers operate accounts and reconcile their own books internally; they don't pass these operational costs onto individual clients as a withdrawal prerequisite.

Your funds are very likely gone. The critical mistake was engaging with an unregulated entity like FXChoice, which has repeatedly been warned about by global regulators, including the FCA. The chances of recovering funds from offshore, unregulated entities are extremely low. However, you should still do the following: 1) Cease all communication with them. 2) Document everything meticulously. 3) Report to MAS immediately. While MAS might not recover your money, your report can contribute to their intelligence gathering and potentially lead to public warnings that save others. Also, consider a chargeback with your bank or card issuer if deposits were made via card and within the chargeback window (usually 120-540 days, depending on your card network).

Lucas Ouellet · Edmonton, Canadaanswered 27d ago
25

Oh god, I felt that in my gut when you said 'low five figures USD'. I was hit by something similar, though with an investment platform that was supposedly for 'green energy bonds'. Ended up losing about $25,000 CAD. They did the whole 'your profits are amazing, just one more fee for 'regulatory compliance'' thing. I was so caught up in the idea of getting my money back that I almost depleted my emergency savings. My husband literally intervened and froze our joint account when he realized what was happening. It was so embarrassing.

I reported it to the Canadian anti-fraud centre (CAFC) but they essentially said because it was an offshore entity, my chances were slim. The feeling of being fooled, and the financial hit, it's just awful. Please, don't pay another cent. They will just keep asking, I promise you. It's a black hole.

Ava Anderson · Ottawa, Canadaanswered 27d ago
15

This is genuinely distressing, Hao, but please, do not send them any more money. This type of 'fee' – 'profit and loss reconciliation' or whatever fancy name they come up with – is 100% a scam. It's a classic red flag in advance fee fraud scenarios common with these unregulated forex/CFD brokers. They create an illusion of profit, hook you in, and then invent these fake administrative costs to bleed you dry as you try to withdraw.

Regulated brokers, like those supervised by the BaFin in Germany or the FCA in the UK, simply do not operate this way. They have clear, transparent fee structures, and none of them involve paying a 'reconciliation fee' to access your own funds. The fact that FXChoice has been flagged by regulators like the FCA tells you everything you need to know. Cut all ties. Block them.

Louise Thomas · Nantes, Franceanswered 27d ago
9

Hao, I'm so sorry you're going through this. It's an incredibly stressful situation, and it's easy to second-guess yourself later. But you're smart for asking before paying this 'fee'. Believe me, the feeling of hope that you might get your money back is exactly what they're banking on.

My friend went through something similar, albeit with a smaller amount, and the emotional toll was huge. She eventually realized it was a lost cause and focused on moving forward. It's incredibly hard to accept, but sometimes cutting your losses is the strongest thing you can do. Take care of yourself, this isn't your fault. These scammers are incredibly sophisticated and manipulative.

Lea Thomas · Lyon, Franceanswered 27d ago
11

Hao, echoing what others have said, this 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a hallmark of a recovery scam embedded within the initial investment scam. They've already taken your money; now they're trying to take even more by preying on your desire to recover it. It's a psychological manipulation tactic.

From a regulatory standpoint, no legitimate financial body (like AFM in the Netherlands or MAS in Singapore) would ever endorse such a fee. Brokers that are properly licensed are subject to stringent financial conduct rules. The very concept of requiring a client to pay for internal accounting reconciliation before a withdrawal is disbursed demonstrates a fundamental disregard for transparent and fair trading practices.

Your primary actions should be: 1. Do not pay another cent. 2. Collect all documentation – emails, payment confirmations, chat logs, screenshots of their website, and any 'invoices' for these fees. 3. File a detailed report with MAS and your local police. While direct recovery is unlikely, these reports are crucial for intelligence gathering and preventing future scams. If you paid by credit/debit card, immediately contact your bank for a chargeback, providing them all your evidence. Time is often of the essence for chargebacks.

Lucas de Vries · Groningen, Netherlandsanswered 27d ago
3

Oh dear, that sounds exactly like a classic advance-fee scam, very common with these types of clone brokers. "FXChoice" itself sounds like a name someone would pick to sound legit but isn't an authorized entity registered with any major regulator like the FCA or BaFin.

The "profit and loss reconciliation fee" or "tax clearance fee" are just made-up ruses. They will keep inventing new fees as long as you pay them. They are not balancing books for any regulator, that's nonsense. This is a well-worn path by scam artists looking to fleece you.

Don't send them another cent. Your money is likely gone unless you can get it back via a chargeback through your bank or card provider, though this is difficult if time has passed.

Emma Byrne · Limerick, Irelandanswered 27d ago
4

Mate, I fell for something eerily similar last year with a broker called OptionStarsGlobal. Started small, then they convinced me to double down. Same story – "regulatory fees", "account upgrades" to get my money out. Told me I had to pay a "compliance fee" to comply with some international AML regs. I paid. Then it was a "liquidity adjustment fee". Each time, a new supposed hurdle. They operate on a purely predatory model. You pay, they invent another reason you need to pay more.

Funnily enough, after I stopped paying and started screaming scam on forums, they went dark. Website gone, contact numbers dead. My funds? Vanished. The only thing I can suggest is check with your bank about a chargeback, but honestly, once the money's with them, it's a long shot. They've got you in their grip with these fake fees. It's brutal.

Lucas Kruger · Port Elizabeth, South Africaanswered 27d ago
2

You know, I've seen this kind of thing pop up a lot. "Profit and loss reconciliation fee"? Sounds like they just made it up on the spot. Why would you, as a client, have to pay to reconcile *their* books? That's their problem, not yours. And especially with the MAS, they're pretty clear about what fees are legitimate. If this FXChoice is offshore and not registered with MAS, it puts them in a murky area anyway.

This whole situation smells fishy. You said they pressured you to deposit more? Red flag. Ignoring withdrawal requests? Red flag. Inventing bizarre fees? Big red flag. I'd be very surprised if you ever see that money again, but definitely don't pay any more fees. It's like feeding a shark. It'll just come back for more.

Aoife Smith · Belfast, Irelandanswered 27d ago
4

This payment structure and the associated "fees" are characteristic of unregulated entities attempting to defraud clients. In many jurisdictions, such as those overseen by the FCA or BaFin, brokers must adhere to strict regulations regarding withdrawals and fees. Any fee presented to a client for the release of their own funds, particularly one that isn't clearly defined in the initial agreement and related to regulatory obligations (e.g., a stamp duty or specific tax), should be treated with extreme suspicion.

"Profit and Loss Reconciliation Fee" is not a standard or legitimate charge for releasing client funds. Its existence suggests the broker is not operating transparently or legitimately. Your primary recourse would have been to confirm broker registration with a reputable financial authority *before* depositing funds. Now, reporting to MAS in Singapore is advisable, but recovery of funds from offshore entities is challenging.

Khalid Al Hashemi · Dubai, UAEanswered 27d ago
3

That sounds *exactly* like a scam. They keep saying "fee" to get more money, and I bet no matter what you pay, they'll come up with another one. My buddy lost about $15k to a similar outfit last year. They hit him with a "withdrawal processing fee", then a "validation fee", then a "currency conversion fee" (even though he deposited in USD). It never ends. The invoice thing is a classic move to make it look official.

Is this "FXChoice" actually regulated by anyone official? Like the CFTC here in the US, or maybe the FCA in the UK? If not, they're probably just pulling this BS on anyone they can. Don't send them any more cash, whatever you do. It's a trap.

Jessica Hall · San Antonio, USAanswered 27d ago
3

Hold on, a "profit and loss reconciliation fee"? That’s not a thing, is it? They're just making it up as they go along. You depositing more money with them after seeing flashy ads already sounds like a warning sign. Then the withdrawal issues and these bizarre fees… yeah, this is textbook. It's a confidence trick to bleed you dry.

My cousin got tangled with a crypto outfit last year, and they kept asking for "verification fees" to release his gains. He paid about $5k in fees. Guess what? No money ever came out. They just ghosted him. This FXChoice sounds like the same scam. Your gut is right. Report them to IC3 (Internet Crime Complaint Center) if you're in the US, or your local equivalent. Keep records of everything.

Daniel O'Neill · Galway, Irelandanswered 27d ago
2

I'd be extremely skeptical of this "fee." It sounds like a phantom charge designed to extract more money from you. Legitimate brokers don't typically charge clients a "profit and loss reconciliation fee" to release funds. That's their internal accounting process. If they were regulated by, say, the FCA or ASIC, there would be clear rules about what fees they can charge. Often, these fake brokers create convincing-looking invoices and documentation to trick people.

I'd check if FXChoice has any actual registration with a financial authority. If they're making up fees, it's a massive red flag. You might want to contact your bank immediately to see if a chargeback is possible, although it's tougher with international transfers and crypto. Also, be sure to file a complaint with the MAS and any international scam reporting agencies, like the FCA's ScamSmart or global ones.

Ashley Johnson · Philadelphia, USAanswered 27d ago
3

Ah, la "commission de rapprochement des profits et pertes" — a classic fabrication by an unscrupulous broker. These entities, often operating without proper authorization from bodies like the AMF in France or other European regulators, prey on the desire for quick profit. They will invent any excuse to retain your capital.

The pressure to increase deposits, followed by fabricated fees for withdrawal, is a well-established pattern of a scam. They aim to extract as much as possible before the client realizes the truth or before the scam operation dissolves. It is highly unlikely this fee is legitimate or that you will see your funds released without further demands. Your instincts are sound; do not pay this fee.

Jules Bernard · Lille, Franceanswered 27d ago
6

Yes, this is it. This is exactly what happened to me. I lost $20k to a scam broker last year. They also said I needed to pay a "tax reconciliation fee" or a "compliance fee" to get my money. They even sent me fake documents that looked like bank transfer confirmations. I was so desperate, I sent them more money, thinking it was the last step. It was a huge mistake. They never sent me anything back. I'm still trying to recover what I can, but it's been a painful lesson. My wife kept telling me it wasn't right, but I was blinded by the hope of getting my money. Don't give them any more money.

Ibrahim Ahmed · Al Ain, UAEanswered 27d ago
5

I am in a similar situation. I deposited $10,000 with a broker that promised incredible returns. When I tried to withdraw, they first asked for a $2,000 "administrative fee." After I paid that, they told me I owed a "capital gains tax" of $5,000 because my profits were so high. They threatened to freeze my account if I didn't pay. I paid the $5,000. Then came the "withdrawal processing fee." That's when I realized I was being scammed. I never saw a dime of my money. These brokers are predators. Please, please do not pay anything else.

Lea Laurent · Paris, Franceanswered 27d ago
3

This is so familiar it hurts. "Profit and loss reconciliation fee"? Sounds like they're just making up official-sounding nonsense. My uncle lost a good chunk of his pension to a forex scammer last year. They were based... somewhere in Eastern Europe, I think. Kept inventing fees every time he tried to withdraw. First it was a "transfer fee," then a "regulatory verification fee," then this "legal compliance tax." It cascaded. They even forged some official-looking document from a non-existent "Global Financial Oversight Committee."

He ended up losing over 30,000 euros. The police here more or less told him there was nothing they could do since the scammers were offshore. Your best bet is to stop all communication and see if your bank can do anything about the initial deposits. Don't pay them another cent.

Alice David · Strasbourg, Franceanswered 27d ago
2

Definitely sounds like a scam. A "profit and loss reconciliation fee" is not a standard charge. If FXChoice is not regulated by a body like ASIC here in Australia, then they have no authority and are likely operating illegally. I've seen scams where they invent all sorts of fees to keep you paying. They might send you fake invoices, like you said, to make it seem legit.

My brother-in-law fell for a similar crypto scam and they kept asking for "verification fees" and "anti-money laundering charges." He paid out nearly $10k in these made-up fees before realizing. They never released any funds. He reported it, but honestly, recovery is very unlikely. Just don't send them any money.

Noah Thompson · Darwin, Australiaanswered 27d ago
6

Warning: This sounds precisely like a "recovery room scam" or an advanced stage of a trading scam. The "profit and loss reconciliation fee" is a fabrication. Legitimate brokers DO NOT charge such fees to release client funds. My neighbor fell victim to a similar scam last year. They were pressured to deposit more, then told they owed a "tax clearance fee" and then a "withdrawal fee." Each time, they invented a new, more complex fee. They lost over $40,000 USD. The broker eventually vanished.

  • Reporting Step: File a report IMMEDIATELY with the MAS (Monetary Authority of Singapore). Also, report to the Singapore Police Force. While MAS regulates financial institutions *in* Singapore, they can still take action or issue warnings about entities targeting Singaporean residents fraudulently.
Daniel Ng · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 27d ago
3

I'm so sorry you're going through this. It sounds incredibly stressful. It's a common tactic for these dodgy brokers to invent fees like this. They want to keep you hooked and bleeding money. My friend also got caught by a similar setup, they called it a "client account maintenance fee" and then a "legal verification charge." They ended up losing their entire investment. It's heartbreaking to see.

Just keep your chin up. Whatever happens, don't send them any more money. You've learned a hard lesson, and it's better to lose the money than to keep throwing good money after bad. Focus on trying to get any help from your bank or MAS, but prepare yourself that recovery might be difficult.

Liam du Plessis · Bloemfontein, South Africaanswered 27d ago
2

This feels very familiar, and not in a good way. The "profit and loss reconciliation fee" is a classic red flag for a scam. It's designed to sound official and necessary, but it's just a made-up hurdle to get more of your money. I've heard stories from friends who got caught by similar operations, often dealing in forex or crypto CFDs. They were told they needed to pay "government taxes" or "international transfer fees" before they could access their funds.

Unfortunately, once these scam brokers have your money, it's incredibly hard to get it back. The best course of action is to stop all communication with them and try to initiate a chargeback with your bank if possible. Also, make sure to report them to the MAS and any other consumer protection agencies you can find.

Sem van den Berg · Amsterdam, Netherlandsanswered 27d ago
5

This is a VERY common scam tactic. The "profit and loss reconciliation fee" is absolute nonsense. They invent these fees to trick you into sending more money. I've seen it happen with scam CFD brokers before. They pressure you to deposit, then when you want to withdraw, it's always "a fee" or "a tax" or "a special clearance."

My cousin lost about $7,000 to one of these. They sent him what looked like an official invoice for a "regulatory fee." He paid it, and then they said he needed to pay a "currency exchange fee." It never ends. The best advice I can give is: STOP PAYMENT. Do not send *any* more money. Report them to MAS and your local police (even if they are offshore). File a chargeback request with your bank immediately.

Aisha Al Mansoori · Al Ain, UAEanswered 27d ago
4

Watch out, this is the standard playbook. They lure you in with promises of high returns, get you to deposit more money, then invent bogus fees like "profit and loss reconciliation" when you try to withdraw. It's a trap. I have a friend who lost their savings to a similar operation last year. They paid about 15,000 AUD in fake "taxes" and "processing fees." The broker eventually stopped replying altogether. These operators are professionals at deception. Tip: Always verify a broker's registration with a reputable financial regulator (like ASIC in Australia, FCA in UK, etc.) BEFORE depositing any money. If they aren't registered or regulated, walk away.

Charlie Green · London, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

Oh mate, this is a classic scam. The "profit and loss reconciliation fee"? That's just pure invention. They'll keep coming up with new fees until you have no money left. My friend lost over $20,000 to a broker who used the exact same tactics – fake invoices, made-up regulatory fees, pressure to deposit more.

It's incredibly disheartening, and I'm really sorry you're going through this. The best thing you can do now is not to send them any more money, no matter what they say. Report this to the MAS, and also check with your bank about disputing the transactions. It's a long shot, but it's worth trying.

Ava Jones · Sydney, Australiaanswered 26d ago
5

This screams scam. A "profit and loss reconciliation fee" is not a legitimate charge for releasing funds. These unregulated brokers invent these fees to try and extract more money. I've seen cases where they demand "tax clearance" or "anti-terrorism financing" fees. It's all fake. Someone I know lost $30,000 to a similar scam last year after they were told they owed a "global transaction fee" to get their money out. Red Flag: If a broker demands upfront fees to release your own profits, it's almost certainly a scam. Report them to the MAS and the police, and see if your bank can help with a chargeback.

Oliver Harris · Hobart, Australiaanswered 26d ago
5

This sounds EXACTLY like the OptionStarsGlobal scam I fell for a few years back. They also hit me with 'taxes' and then 'fees' to 'reconcile' my supposed profits. They invented a whole story about needing to appease financial regulators. It's all theatre to keep you sending them money. The FCA in the UK (if they claim to be regulated there) or even your local MAS (Monetary Authority of Singapore) won't get your money back if the entity is offshore and fraudulent, but they *will* want to know about it. Reporting them might help prevent others from falling victim. Don't send them another cent.

Alice Moreau · Lille, Franceanswered 26d ago
7

Oh man, I know that stress. My first broker did the same thing. Told me I had to pay a 'compliance fee' to release my 'profits'. I was so desperate, I actually sent them another $2k. BIG mistake. They disappeared shortly after. Turns out, they weren't regulated anywhere. The only way I got *any* of my original deposit back was by filing a chargeback with my credit card company. It took MONTHS, but Visa worked with me. Did you deposit via credit card? If so, contact your bank ASAP. That's your best shot.

Sara Al Marri · Dubai, UAEanswered 26d ago
3

FXChoice, eh? Never heard of them trying that specific 'reconciliation' line, but it reeks of the same old scam playbook. Unregulated brokers love inventing fees. 'Tax clearance'? 'Profit and loss reconciliation'? Give me a break. If they were legitimate, those costs would be part of their operational expenses, not something they charge unsuspecting clients. Were they ever regulated by the FCA or similar? If not, you're likely dealing with pure criminals. Sorry, but just being honest. It's a tough lesson.

Aoife Burke · Belfast, Irelandanswered 26d ago
6

Hang in there. What you're describing is a classic pump-and-dump, disguised as a broker. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is pure fabrication. They don't have regulators needing that; you do. They just want more cash. I lost 10k to 'Global Trade Markets' doing the same thing. They wanted a 'validation fee' next. My wife told me to report them to the CFTC in the US, even though I'm not in the US. It didn't get my money back but it did get their website flagged.

Niklas Schulz · Cologne, Germanyanswered 26d ago
4

Gosh, that sounds incredibly stressful. I'm really sorry you're going through this. It's good you're questioning the fee – that's a huge red flag. These brokers often invent fees to string you along. Don't pay it. Seriously. Sending more money will just make them ask for another fee. Focus on what steps you can take *without* sending more funds. Maybe check if they're falsely claiming to be registered with any national authority? Sometimes a quick search on the MAS website (since you're in SG) can confirm if they're legit or not.

William Roy · Vancouver, Canadaanswered 26d ago
5

This is textbook. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is purely an invention designed to extract further funds from you under the guise of legitimacy. Brokers don't charge clients fees to appease their own regulators; that's absurd. If they are claiming to be regulated by an authority like the FCA or BaFin, check that authority's register directly. Many scam operations falsely claim affiliation with reputable bodies. If they are not listed on the relevant regulator's register, they are operating illegally. Never send additional funds for such phantom fees.

Oliver Wood · Birmingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

Mate, I've heard variations of this before. They reel you in with promises, then hit you with these made-up charges when you try to get out. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds particularly ridiculous. It's designed to sound official, right? Like they're being super transparent. But really, it's just smoke and mirrors. You're right to be suspicious. The best defence is just not paying it. What else have they mentioned? Sometimes they escalate to 'anti-money laundering' fees or 'transfer fees' next.

Saar Visser · Tilburg, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
5

I've been there, friend. My 'advisor' (total scammer) told me I owed a 'capital gains tax adjustment fee' before they'd release my funds. It was a load of rubbish. I ended up reporting them to the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) here in SA, though I know it's not the same as MAS. They took my details, but my money was gone. The advice is: STOP sending them money. They'll just invent new fees forever. If you used a credit card, try a chargeback IMMEDIATELY.

Naledi Ndlovu · Port Elizabeth, South Africaanswered 26d ago
5

This is a familiar tune. These boiler-room operations are all run from the same playbook. Fees upon fees. 'Release fee', 'tax fee', 'reconciliation fee'... it never ends. The key is to stop communicating with them about *paying* anything. They'll love-bomb you with fake profits and then scare you with fake fees. My broker, 'ProfitMax', tried the same. Sent me a fake invoice and everything. I reported them to the Texas State Securities Board and the CFTC. Didn't get my money back, but it slowed them down.

Jessica Martin · Houston, USAanswered 26d ago
4

From a regulatory perspective, the concept of a 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' charged to an individual retail client is highly irregular, bordering on fictitious. Legitimate brokers operating under strict regulatory oversight (like the FCA or BaFin) handle their own internal reconciliation and tax reporting as part of their operational costs. They do not levy such direct fees to clients post-trade for this purpose. Your broker is likely not regulated, or is operating outside its permitted scope. Check the official register of the regulator they claim to be authorised by. Most regulators have an online database.

Niamh O'Neill · Belfast, Irelandanswered 26d ago
6

WARNING! Do NOT pay this fee. FXChoice if they are asking for this is a SCAM. They will invent more fees. I lost money to one of these outfits called 'Prime Capital'. They wanted an 'international transfer fee' after the fake 'tax fee'. It's designed to make you think it's all official, but it's just theft. Look into chargeback if you paid by card. Also, report them to the AFM (Dutch authority) if they claim any Dutch connection at all, or even if not, they log complaints.

Liam Janssen · Groningen, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
5

This happened to me too. They told me I had to pay a 'withdrawal processing fee' which was 10% of my supposed profit. I argued and argued. Finally, they said it was mandatory for 'international clients'. I was so angry, I nearly payed it. My cousin, who works in finance, stopped me. He told me these are classic scam tactics. He advised me to file a complaint with the MAS (Monetary Authority of Singapore) immediately – even if they are offshore, MAS tracks these complaints. It didn't get my money back, but it's on their record.

Mohammed Sheikh · Sharjah, UAEanswered 26d ago
5

Yeah, I recognize the pattern. I was with a similar outfit – they called themselves 'SecureFX'. Tried to get me to pay a 'security deposit refund fee'. Total nonsense. They took about $15k of mine. I even remember them sending me scary-looking documents that looked like official government forms. My wife told me to contact the ASIC (Australian Securities and Investments Commission) because the broker had a fake AU address. It didn't recover my funds but it did get their website flagged for phishing.

Daniel Smith · Cork, Irelandanswered 26d ago
6

Oh mate, I'm so sorry. I know exactly what you're going through. I lost €8k to a broker called 'ZenithFX' last year. They kept asking for 'verification fees' and then sudden 'tax payments'. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is their latest trick, I reckon. It sounds so official, doesn't it? But it's a total lie. Whatever you do, don't send them any more money. These people prey on our hope. My advice? Contact your bank and see if a chargeback is possible. It's your only real chance.

Daniel Lau · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
5

This is incredibly frustrating. You're right to be suspicious. These 'fees' are a classic tactic to bleed you dry. If they're claiming regulation, especially by a body like the FCA or MAS, always, *always* check the regulator’s official website for their license number. Scammers often fake these or use numbers of legitimate but unrelated firms. If the license isn't verifiable *on the regulator's site*, it's fake. Don't pay another penny.

Thomas Wilson · Manchester, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
6

SCAM ALERT! SCAM ALERT! This is exactly how they got me. They also hit me with a 'profit reconciliation fee' after I questioned a 'tax fee'. They even sent me a fake 'certificate of exemption' when I didn't want to pay the tax. They are thieves. Never pay them. Report them to the CFTC if they have any US ties. They are not regulated and have no intention of letting you withdraw anything. Stick to regulated brokers only.

Charlotte MacDonald · Victoria, Canadaanswered 26d ago
5

Don't pay it. It's a scam. They will invent another fee. And another. And another. I got hit with a similar 'administrative fee' from a broker called 'Global Invest Pro'. Took my £12k. It’s designed to sound legit, make you feel like just a little more effort and you'll get your money. It's a trap. Seriously, contact your credit card company and start a chargeback dispute NOW if you used a card. That's your best hope. MAS is good for reporting, but chargeback is for recovering.

Tyler Brown · Denver, USAanswered 26d ago
5

This is a known scam tactic. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds professional but is completely made up. They want to keep you hooked, hoping you’ll pay more. Don't fall for it. If they claim to be regulated anywhere, check that regulator's website *directly*. For example, if they claim FCA regulation, go to the FCA website and search their register. Do not trust what the broker tells you; verify everything independently. They are robbers.

Saoirse Byrne · Cork, Irelandanswered 26d ago
4

Yeah, that's a classic. They'll keep inventing fees until you run out of money or realise it's a scam. 'Profit and loss reconciliation' is just their latest excuse. They’re not reconciling anything for regulators; they're trying to reconcile your bank account with theirs! Report them to the MAS if you haven't already. Even if they are offshore, your report goes into their system and might help them shut down these operations or warn others.

Lucas Simon · Marseille, Franceanswered 26d ago
5

This is pure scam. They want your money. Don't pay them anything else. They will never release your funds. I lost a lot to a similar scam. They are not real brokers. Report EVERYTHING to the MAS. It helps build a case against them and warns other people. But honestly, the best bet for money back is a credit card chargeback. Act fast!

Chloe Martin · Nice, Franceanswered 26d ago
6

Oh wow, that sounds like a classic advance-fee scam. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is completely made up, designed to extract more money before they ghost you. FXChoice is known for this kind of behavior – they aren't a real, regulated broker. They love targeting people with promises of quick riches and then invent fees to avoid payouts. The MAS in Singapore is your best bet for filing a complaint, even for offshore entities, but honestly, recovery is tough once the money is gone. Always check regulatory bodies like the FCA or CFTC before depositing ANY money. They usually have warning lists. Don't send them another cent.

Amelia Cote · Ottawa, Canadaanswered 26d ago
5

Oh gosh, that sounds like an absolute nightmare. I'm so sorry you're going through this. Those fees sound completely bogus. It's like they just keep inventing reasons! Please try not to stress too much, easier said than done I know. Is there anyone you can talk to in person about this? Sometimes just venting helps a little. Keep your chin up, and remember, you're not alone in this. Many people fall for these things, it's the scammers who are the problem, not you.

Sophie Harris · Darwin, Australiaanswered 26d ago
4

A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? Seriously? Sounds like a complete load of codswallop. They're just making it up as they go along, aren't they? Unregulated brokers, especially those pushing crypto CFDs, are notorious for this. They'll invent taxes, compliance fees, administrative charges... anything to get another payment. I'd be very surprised if you see a single cent back, tbh. Did they even provide any regulatory registration number that's verifiable? Most likely not.

Niamh Walsh · Cork, Irelandanswered 26d ago
7

Oh god, I've been there. Exact same thing. I used OptionStarsGlobal a couple years ago. Started small, they said I needed more capital for 'premium access' to profitable trades. Then when I wanted to pull out my initial deposit (forget profits!), they hit me with a 'withdrawal processing fee' and then an 'anti-money laundering verification fee'. They sent me official-looking documents too. It felt so real. I paid them maybe $1500 total after the initial deposit to 'clear' it. Never saw a penny. They just stopped responding. I reported it to my local police and even the CFTC, but nothing ever came of it. It's heartbreaking when you realize your savings are just gone. I learned my lesson the hard way: if it sounds too good to be true, it IS. And never, ever pay extra fees to release funds. That's the final nail in the coffin.

Laura Becker · Hamburg, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

WARNING: This is a very common scam tactic used by unregulated FX and crypto platforms. They operate offshore specifically to avoid oversight. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is NOT real. It's a fabricated charge designed to take your money. They will likely invent more fees if you pay this one. The best course of action is to cease all communication and report them. For your situation in Singapore, file a report with the MAS (Monetary Authority of Singapore). Also consider reporting to the ACRA (Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority) and potentially Interpol if the amounts are substantial. Do NOT send them any more money.

Lucas Khumalo · Port Elizabeth, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

My heart goes out to you. This is exactly what happened to me last year with a different platform. They promised the world, then the withdrawal requests turned into a bureaucratic nightmare. First it was 'verification fees,' then 'taxes,' and then they invented something called a 'compliance adjustment charge.' It was so demoralizing. I ended up losing thousands. They sent me fake invoices and even simulated statements. It's sickening how they prey on people's hopes. I wish I'd never even heard of them. I've learned to be extremely wary of anyone who promises guaranteed high returns, especially with crypto.

Rachel Wood · Cardiff, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
6

This is textbook. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee', like the 'tax clearance fee' before it, is pure fabrication. They create these elaborate-sounding names to give a veneer of legitimacy to their demands. FXChoice is unfortunately a known entity in these scams. They operate outside of credible regulatory frameworks like the FCA or ASIC. If they were legitimate, such a fee wouldn't exist. You should immediately stop all communication with them and consider reporting it to the MAS. You can also file a complaint with the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) if they have any Australian links or marketing, as misleading financial services are their purview. Don't pay another cent.

Charlie Wilson · Canberra, Australiaanswered 26d ago
5

Ugh, I've heard of this playbook before. My neighbour's son fell for something similar with a binary options site last year. He was persuaded to deposit more, then when he wanted to cash out, they demanded a 'capital gains tax payment' and a 'compliance verification fee'. He paid about AUD $5k extra on top of his initial $10k deposit. Total loss. He was devastated. He eventually reported it to ASIC, but they said since the company was offshore and not licensed by ASIC, their hands were tied beyond issuing warnings. He never got his money back. It's a cruel scam.

Eva de Groot · Tilburg, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
7

This sounds exactly like my situation. I'm in Singapore too, and I dealt with a scam broker called OptionStarsGlobal. They also used the 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' excuse. It was so convincing, they even sent me an official-looking PDF statement. I paid it, thinking it was the final step. It wasn't. They then asked for an 'international transfer fee.' That's when I knew for sure. I lost SGD $8,000. I filed a report with MAS, and they were helpful in acknowledging it, but they stressed that for offshore entities with no Singapore presence, recovery is extremely difficult. They did give me advice though: if a platform asks for ANY upfront fee to release your own money, it's a scam. Block and report.

Hannah Lim · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
6

Oh mate, I feel sick reading this. It's exactly what happened to me a year ago. Unregulated broker, promised the moon. Wanted to withdraw $5k, they said I owed an 'administrative fee' and a 'regulatory compliance charge'. I was so naive, I transferred them another $800. Dumbest mistake. They vanished after that. I reported them to the FCA, but they weren't regulated by them, so there was little they could do. It's a brutal lesson. Now, I only use brokers that are directly regulated by the FCA or BaFin. Check their registration numbers meticulously on the regulator's website. If it's not there, walk away.

Rachel Hall · Nottingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

I'm so sorry, this is devastating. Reading your post makes my stomach churn because it’s so similar to what my cousin went through. She invested with a platform that promised huge crypto returns and ended up being hit with multiple fake fees just to withdraw her initial $2,000. They called it a 'bank processing fee' and then a 'currency conversion adjustment'. She paid them religiously until she had no money left. She’s still heartbroken about it. The biggest thing she learned, and what she always tells me now, is that if you have to pay money to get your money out, it’s a scam. Every single time.

Olivia Gagne · Toronto, Canadaanswered 26d ago
7

This is precisely the same scam I encountered with a broker called 'Global Trade FX' (might be a different name now). They wanted a ridiculous 'international transfer fee' after I'd already 'paid' a 'liquidity provider charge'. It sounded official, complete with an invoice that looked like it came from a bank. I sent them money via wire transfer – stupid, I know. They disappeared after that. My savings are gone. For reporting, I contacted the CFTC here in the US, and they took a report, but said recovery from offshore entities is extremely difficult. They did, however, point me towards resources on how to spot red flags. The main one they stressed: Never pay fees to release funds. Especially not 'reconciliation' or 'tax' fees.

Lucas Johnson · Melbourne, Australiaanswered 26d ago
6

Oh dear, this sounds painfully familiar. I narrowly escaped this exact situation with a forex broker a couple of years back. They kept pushing me to deposit more and more, promising VIP status. When I finally tried to withdraw a portion, they invented a 'regulatory oversight fee'. They even sent me a PDF that looked like an official letter from some European financial authority. I was so close to paying it, but then I decided to double-check the supposed regulator's website. Found out the regulator didn't even exist! It was a huge red flag. I immediately cut contact. Always, always verify the regulator they claim to be registered with. If they can't provide a verifiable registration number or the regulator doesn't exist/doesn't license them, it's a scam. Report them to the AFM if they claim any Dutch connection, or your local securities regulator.

Olivia Lavoie · Edmonton, Canadaanswered 26d ago
4

A profit and loss reconciliation fee... that's a new one on me, and I've heard a lot of scammer excuses. Sounds utterly ridiculous. So, they're asking you to pay them so they can... file paperwork? For regulators? That doesn't make any sense. Legitimate brokers handle their own regulatory reporting. They don't demand extra fees from clients for it. They are just bleeding you dry. I assume they are not regulated by BaFin in Germany or any other serious authority? Your best bet is to cut your losses and report them to the MAS. Don't send any more money, you won't get it back.

Paul Becker · Leipzig, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

This is exactly what happened to me. I invested with a similar broker, and they kept asking for more money. First it was a 'transfer fee,' then a 'license fee.' I lost about $5,000 before I realized it was a scam. I reported it to my bank, Capitec, but they said once the money left my account and went offshore, there was nothing they could do. It’s heartbreaking. Your best bet is to report this to IC3.gov if you have any US nexus, otherwise, check with the MAS. But honestly, don't expect to get your money back. It's a lesson learned the hard way.

Sarah du Plessis · Cape Town, South Africaanswered 26d ago
6

Oh nee, this sounds awful. This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is definitely a scam. They make these up to confuse you and get more money. I’ve seen it with dodgy crypto platforms here. They’ll say you owe taxes, or admin fees, or some other nonsense. They're not real. Your bank, like ABN AMRO or ING, usually can't help much once the money is gone, especially if it’s gone offshore. The AFM (Autoriteit Financiële Markten) is the regulator here, but they can only act if the company has ties to the Netherlands. Your best step is to report it to MAS in Singapore, and also put a warning out on forums like this. Never pay fees to release your own funds.

Lucas de Boer · Almere, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
5

This is a total scam. FXChoice is not a regulated entity. The fees they're asking for are fabricated. This is a common advance-fee fraud. They lull you into a false sense of security with initial 'profits' (which are just numbers on a screen) and then invent fees to keep you sending money. You likely won't see your funds again. Report them to the MAS in Singapore. They can at least add them to their investor alert list. Also, check if they have any presence or advertising in Australia, and if so, report them to ASIC and the ACCC too. Don't send them anything else.

Jia Ong · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
4

Sounds like a classic scam. They invent fees out of thin air. I've heard of 'account maintenance fees', 'transfer fees', 'tax clearance', and now this 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'. It’s all designed to get more cash from you. If they were regulated by, say, the FCA in the UK, they wouldn't be asking for this. They'd have proper procedures. They're just making it up. I'm sorry, but you're probably not getting that money back. Cut contact and report them to the MAS. That's all you can really do at this point.

Daniel Smith · Cork, Irelandanswered 26d ago
6

What a nightmare. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds completely made up. That’s not a thing in legitimate finance for retail investors. They're just trying to squeeze more money out of you. I'd be extremely wary. Have you checked if they're regulated by the CFTC or even BaFin? If they aren't registered with a reputable authority, it's a huge red flag. I'd advise you to stop all communication and report them to the MAS. They might not be able to recover your funds, but they can warn others. And please, never pay fees to release your own money. That's the oldest trick in the book.

Sophie Schmidt · Munich, Germanyanswered 26d ago
8

This sounds textbook. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' isn't a real thing brokers ask for. They invent fees as you get close to withdrawing money, and they never stop piling them on. These usually unregulated outfits like FXChoice operate on a Ponzi-like structure. They need new money to pay old investors. When you try to get your money out, the whole thing collapses. It's a way to bleed you dry before they vanish.

Don't pay them another cent. Seriously. Your best bet is to report them to wherever they advertise heavily. If they targeted you in Canada, report it to the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre. Also, file a report with your bank – if you used a credit card or wire transfer, there's a small chance they can do a chargeback, though it's tough with offshore entities.

Noah Gagne · Calgary, Canadaanswered 26d ago
6

oh god yes. i've been there. not FXChoice specifically, but felt like the same playbook. started small, wife kept saying 'be careful', then they said i needed to 'show more commitment' for a better risk profile. then came the 'admin fee', then the 'withdrawal processing fee', which magically turned into a 'tax liability' after i questioned it. it's a carousel of made-up charges. i lost… well, a lot. enough that we had to sell our second car. it changed everything for us. i paid the last 'fee' thinking it would be the final one. it never was. never again.

Mia Schulz · Hamburg, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? Seriously? Sounds like total BS to me. They just make stuff up as they go along. If they were legit, they wouldn't need some random fee to 'balance the books'. Especially for crypto CFDs, which are already super volatile. Maybe it's just a way for them to stall? Did you check if FXChoice is even regulated by anyone reputable like the FCA or BaFin? Probably not. Ngl I'd be very suspicious.

Noor Sheikh · Ajman, UAEanswered 26d ago
10

This is exactly what happened to me! Except it was with OptionStarsGlobal, not FXChoice. They told me I had to pay a 'regulatory compliance fee' before they could release my funds. I was in shock. I'm in Singapore too, and I remember thinking the MAS wouldn't cover overseas brokers or something like that. I paid it because I was so desperate to get my money out. Big mistake. That wasn't a real fee, just another scam. I lost SGD 15k. I truly hope you haven't paid anything yet. Please don't.

Joshua Koh · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
4

Oh man, that sounds rough. I haven't personally dealt with FXChoice but I've heard similar stories from friends in other groups. It's always the same – when you want to take your money out, they invent some nonsense fee. Don't let them bully you into paying more. They rely on people being stressed and making rash decisions. Keep pushing back, and if possible, try reporting them to consumer protection agencies in your country. Sometimes it doesn't get the money back, but it might stop them from scamming others.

Thabo Pretorius · Port Elizabeth, South Africaanswered 26d ago
7

This P&L fee thing… that's a new one on me, but honestly, not surprising. After losing a fair bit to a shady outfit myself a few years back (they called it an 'international transfer tax'), I learned that these invented fees are the last resort of scammers. They drain you to the bone. It’s gutting. I remember my husband saying, 'just let it go,' but I couldn't. The psychological toll is immense. You feel so stupid, so greedy. Try to get out now before you lose more. Maybe check if your credit card provider offers any protection, though it's probably a long shot.

Laura Bauer · Cologne, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

Hey, I'm so sorry you're going through this. It sounds like a classic scam. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is totally made up. Legitimate brokers don't operate like that. They are trying to get more money from you. You're right to be suspicious.

My advice: Stop all communication with them about payments. If you've used a bank transfer, contact your bank immediately to see if you can reverse the transaction, although I know it's difficult with international transfers. You probably won't get your money back, but don't pay them another penny. They're just hoping you'll keep paying fees until you have nothing left.

Charlie Hall · Cardiff, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
6

Yeah, this 'reconciliation fee' sounds like pure fiction. These shady brokers, especially ones dealing in exotic stuff like crypto CFDs, invent fees to squeeze every last dollar out. I bet if you paid it, they'd just come up with another one. It's a common tactic. I'd check if FXChoice is regulated by the FCA or another major body. If not, you're dealing with likely criminals. Don't pay.

Sean Ryan · Waterford, Irelandanswered 26d ago
9

This P&L fee is a massive red flag. It’s not a thing. They invent these excuses to fleece you. I've seen it happen to mates. They'll invent a ‘tax charge’, an ‘anti-money laundering compliance fee’, a ‘software update fee’… anything. They pray you haven't checked their regulatory status. If FXChoice isn't registered with a reputable authority like the FCA (in the UK) or ASIC (in Australia), then you're dealing with a scam. Don't send them any more money. Report them everywhere you can.

Rachel Wright · London, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

Oh dear, that sounds awfully familiar. It's heartbreaking to hear you're caught in this. These platforms, they prey on hope. The fees are designed to keep you hooked while they drain your account. It’s a cruel game.

Fighting back is hard, especially when they are offshore. But please, please don't pay that fee. It won't be the last. Think of it as a costly lesson. Try to find out if your bank has any fraud department that might help trace the money, but honestly, it’s a long shot with these types of operations.

Lily Mokoena · East London, South Africaanswered 26d ago
7

This is a common scam. They call it by different names – 'profit reconciliation fee', 'account settlement charge', 'escrow release fee'. It’s all just fabricated to get more money from you. FXChoice is likely not regulated, or uses fake licenses. If you can, report them to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), especially if they have any marketing presence here. Reporting helps flag them even if they can't recover your funds.

Noah Johnson · Hobart, Australiaanswered 26d ago
5

Definitely a scam. That fee doesn't exist. They are trying to get more of your money. Your MAS mentioned is a good point – while they regulate Singapore-based entities, they also maintain a warning list of overseas firms that are unlicensed or suspicious. Check that list. If FXChoice is on it, or if they have no regulation listed at all on a site like BaFin or FCA, then it's a scam. Don't pay.

Noor Al Hashemi · Sharjah, UAEanswered 26d ago
3

Hang in there! It’s scary when they pull stuff like this. My cousin got hit with something similar last year with a different forex platform. They said he owed 'capital gains tax' on unrealized profits. He nearly paid it! But we talked him down and sent him links to consumer protection sites. He didn't get his money back, but at least he didn't lose more. You're doing the right thing by asking here.

Oliver Brown · Perth, Australiaanswered 26d ago
8

This whole 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' screams scam. A legitimate broker's reconciliation should be part of their normal operations, not an extra charge to the client for withdrawal. It sounds like they're trying to hit you with a made-up tax or fee just before payout.

Check the regulatory status of FXChoice with the FCA or the German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin). If they aren't registered with a strict regulator, they are likely unregulated and operating fraudulently. Any fee they demand now is almost certainly a way to steal more money. Do not pay it.

Hao Chan · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
5

Mate, that fee sounds like pure nonsense. I've seen claims about FXChoice being dodgy. They probably don't have any real regulation behind them. If they were regulated by, say, the CFTC in the US, they wouldn't be doing this. It's the oldest trick in the book – invent a fee to get more money when you ask for a withdrawal. I'd say cut your losses and report them to whoever they targeted you through.

Noah Smith · Canberra, Australiaanswered 26d ago
7

Ugh, I feel for you. This same thing happened to my friend, different broker name but same tactic. They introduced a 'compliance fee' and then a 'client verification fee.' It just kept going. She ended up losing basically everything. It's horrible. I really hope you haven't paid anything yet. Please, whatever you do, do not send them more money. They are professionals at this.

Emily Brown · Liverpool, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

This P&L reconciliation fee is a total scam. I've seen it before with unregulated crypto platforms. They just keep coming up with new fees to steal your money. Don't pay it. Report them to your local financial regulator, even if they are offshore. Also, check your bank statements for any dispute options through your card provider or bank. It's unlikely but worth a try.

Conor Ryan · Dublin, Irelandanswered 26d ago
6

Sending you strength. This sounds like a classic scamming technique. When you try to withdraw funds, they invent fees to keep you from getting your money back. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is almost certainly not real. Your MAS in Singapore can help with local entities, but for offshore brokers, it's tougher. You might want to report them to IC3 (Internet Crime Complaint Center) in the US, as many of these operations are based there.

Charlie Smith · Manchester, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
5

Oh no, that's awful. I've seen similar stories. That fee is a huge red flag. It's not a real thing. They just make up fees to keep you paying. Your gut feeling is spot on. Seriously, stop talking to them about money. I wouldn't pay anything more. I'd also try filing a report with the FCA if they have any UK presence, or any other regulatory body they claim to be associated with. You probably won't get your money back, but reporting them is important.

Emma Schafer · Leipzig, Germanyanswered 26d ago
7

Man, I'm so sorry. This is exactly how they get you. I'm in Germany and I had a friend lose a small fortune to something similar online. They invented a 'currency conversion fee' after my friend tried to withdraw EUR. It never ended. He's still paying off debts from it. Honestly, never pay these phantom fees. Cut your losses and report them. Maybe the AFM in the Netherlands could help if FXChoice has any links there.

Thomas Schmidt · Dresden, Germanyanswered 26d ago
6

This smells very much like a classic advance-fee scam, unfortunately. FXChoice is not a regulated entity anywhere I can verify via the FCA, CFTC, or BaFin registers. They're likely operating offshore and creating fake fees to bleed you dry. A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is not a standard industry charge. It's a made-up term designed to sound legitimate. Don't send them any more money. Your best bet is to try and file a complaint with IC3 (Internet Crime Complaint Center) if you used US banking or payment channels, and also report it to the MAS in Singapore, even if they are offshore. Document EVERYTHING.

Noah Smith · Quebec City, Canadaanswered 26d ago
5

Oh mate, I've been there. EXACTLY the same thing happened to me with OptionStarsGlobal, or some other name they use. They wanted all sorts of fees – 'verification fees', 'compliance fees', even a 'liquidity adjustment fee' once. It's all BS to get your money. I ended up losing about 15k AUD. The feeling of helplessness is crushing. I'm still trying to claw some of it back, but honestly... mostly just trying to warn others now. You have my sympathies, truly.

James Walker · Birmingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
5

This is a textbook red flag, please stop sending funds. FXChoice is not licensed by the FCA or any reputable regulator. Fees like this 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' are invented to trick victims into paying more. They create fake invoices and professional-sounding emails to appear legitimate. If you feel pressured to pay, that’s another big warning sign. Scammers thrive on urgency and fear. Don't let them exploit your stress. Gather all your documentation and report this to the authorities.

Sarah Kruger · Durban, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

I fell for a similar story last year with a crypto outfit that also claimed to be an FX broker. Started small, then they pressured me for more to 'unlock' bigger profits. When I wanted to withdraw, they hit me with 'admin fees' and 'currency conversion charges'. I paid a couple of thousand more before I realised I was just throwing good money after bad. Lost about ten grand total. FXChoice is likely another boiler room operation. Report them to ASIC if you can, and also your local police for fraud.

Mia Taylor · Canberra, Australiaanswered 26d ago
4

Based on your description, this strongly aligns with common fraud patterns employed by unregulated brokers. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fabricated charge. Reputable financial institutions and regulated brokers do not levy such arbitrary fees for withdrawals. If FXChoice is indeed soliciting clients from Singapore, MAS would be the primary regulatory body, but recovering funds from offshore entities can be challenging. Always verify broker registration with the relevant financial authorities before depositing funds. In your case, checking the MAS registry is crucial. Since they are not listed, it's a clear indication of a scam.

Fatima Al Mansoori · Ras Al Khaimah, UAEanswered 26d ago
4

I'm so sorry you're going through this. It sounds exactly like what happened to my uncle. He invested with a broker that promised the moon and then demanded a 'tax fee' to release his 'profits.' He paid it, then they invented another fee. He ended up losing his entire life savings. He was devastated and too embarrassed to even tell us for months. We eventually reported it, but the money was gone. This seems like a very common scam tactic.

Thomas Davies · Nottingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

You're not alone, mate. I got caught by a 'Forex broker' that kept inventing reasons why I couldn't get my money out. First it was verification, then a 'withdrawal processing fee', then this exact 'profit reconciliation' nonsense. They even sent me a fake regulatory document. Told my wife I was almost cleaned out. I lost a pretty penny, felt like such an idiot. Had to report it to the Gardaí fraud unit eventually. Didn't get anything back, but at least it's on record. Stay strong, don't send them more.

Conor Lynch · Waterford, Irelandanswered 26d ago
4

This sounds eerily familiar. I lost money to a similar scam a few years back. They kept asking for more funds to 'cover taxes' or 'release profits.' I paid maybe $5,000 CAD in fake fees before my wife finally convinced me it was a scam. I felt so stupid and ashamed. The broker was supposedly regulated, but when I checked properly, they weren't registered with the proper Canadian authorities. Your gut feeling is right. Don't send them another cent. Report them everywhere you can – like the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre.

Amelia MacDonald · Winnipeg, Canadaanswered 26d ago
4

This is devastating. I'm dealing with something similar right now with a crypto platform, not a Forex one, but the pattern is identical. They're demanding a 'security deposit' to release my funds - they say it's standard procedure for large withdrawals and to prevent fraud on my end. I'm in about $8,000 USD currently and they're asking for another $2,000. I'm so scared and losing sleep over it. This is turning into my worst nightmare.

Noah Tremblay · Calgary, Canadaanswered 26d ago
4

I understand how stressful this must be. Regarding your situation in Singapore, while MAS supervision is key for local brokers, they do have channels for reporting suspected scams even involving offshore entities. You should definitely file a report with them. Also, check if FXChoice has any presence or claims to be regulated by other authorities like the FCA in the UK or ASIC in Australia. If they do, report them there too. Every report adds to the pressure on these scam operations.

Samuel Ng · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
4

This is heartbreaking to read. It's like a script they all use. I lost a significant amount to a scam broker called 'Global Trade FX' a while back. They also manufactured 'fees' – processing fees, capital gains tax fees, everything. My husband was so angry when he found out how much I'd lost. I ended up reporting it to the South African Police Service and the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA). It didn't get my money back, but they need to know.

Sophie Smit · Cape Town, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? Seriously? Sounds like something they just pulled out of thin air. If you deposited money via a credit card, check if you can still do a chargeback. That's a long shot after some time, but worth looking into. Otherwise, reporting it is really your only recourse. Don't expect to get the money back, tbh, but you might help stop them from doing it to someone else.

Michael Pillay · Port Elizabeth, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

I am so sorry to hear this. It sounds like a very common scam. They always have a reason why you can't withdraw your money. A fee that sounds official but is completely made up. Maybe try reaching out to consumer protection agencies in Singapore? They might not be able to recover your funds directly, but they could offer advice or help with the reporting process. Stay strong, and don't give them any more of your money.

Louise Richard · Nantes, Franceanswered 26d ago
4

Yeah, this sounds like a scam. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' isn't a real thing. They probably cooked it up. If you paid by credit card, try calling your bank and see about a chargeback – explain it was for an investment that turned out to be fraudulent. Otherwise, report it to the local authorities and maybe some international scam reporting sites. Good luck, hope you get something back, but don't count on it.

Isla Nguyen · Gold Coast, Australiaanswered 26d ago
4

You have my full sympathy. This is a very distressing situation. When dealing with offshore brokers, it's critical to verify their regulatory status with bodies like the FCA or ASIC. If FXChoice is not listed, it's a massive red flag. The fees they are inventing are a known tactic. Reporting to MAS is a good step, and also consider filing a complaint with the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) if any part of the transaction involved the US financial system.

Daniel Pillay · Port Elizabeth, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

Ugh, this sounds awful. I had a similar thing happen with a binary options site years ago. They kept asking for 'verification fees' and 'withdrawal fees.' I paid about $2k before realising it was a total scam. My husband was furious. I reported them to the cybercrime unit here in SA. It’s a horrible feeling when you realise you’ve been duped out of your hard-earned cash. Be careful, check regulators!

Emily Jones · Austin, USAanswered 26d ago
4

This is a known scam pattern. These unregulated brokers invent fees like 'profit and loss reconciliation' to extort more money. They play on your fear and hope that you'll pay to get your 'investments' out. Report them to the relevant authorities in Singapore (MAS) and also to international bodies like the FBI's IC3. Document every single communication and transaction. Don't send them any more money. I've seen this happen to friends, and it's devastating.

Emma Khumalo · Durban, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

This is deeply concerning, and sadly, a very common scam tactic. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is almost certainly fictitious. Legitimate brokers do not operate this way. Your first step should be to gather all your evidence – emails, invoices, transaction records. Then, file a formal complaint with the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS), detailing the entire interaction, including the fake fees. Also, check if FXChoice claims any affiliation with regulated entities like the FCA or ASIC and report them there as well. Prevention is key: always verify broker registration with regulatory bodies *before* investing.

Daniel Jackson · Austin, USAanswered 26d ago
4

I'm really sorry you're going through this. It sounds incredibly stressful. From what you've described, it strongly suggests a scam. The fees are likely fabricated. For reporting, besides MAS, you might consider if any of your transactions went through US payment processors; if so, the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) is a resource. You can file a report there. It's unlikely to recover funds directly, but it helps build a case against these fraudulent operations.

Joshua Miller · Austin, USAanswered 26d ago
4

This is exactly how they get you! My friend lost about R200k ZAR from a similar broker. They started with a small withdrawal, then invented a 'tax fee' for the next one, then another fake fee. It’s like a snowball rolling downhill. Check if FXChoice is regulated by the FSCA in South Africa, or any other major regulator like the FCA. If not, don't trust them. Report them to MAS, IC3, and anyone else you can think of. It's tough, but don't send them more cash.

Emma Nel · East London, South Africaanswered 26d ago
5

This smells like a classic advance fee scam, mate. FXChoice isn't regulated by any major body like the FCA or CFTC. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a made-up charge. They'll keep asking for more fees – 'transfer fees', 'compliance fees', etc. – until you either pay them all or realize it's a dead end. Unregulated brokers often use these tactics. If they told you to 'put in more' to see profits, that's already a massive red flag. Genuine brokers don't pressure clients like that.

Daniel Lynch · Galway, Irelandanswered 26d ago
3

Oh wow, that sounds incredibly stressful. I'm so sorry you're going through this. It's completely understandable that you're worried sick. Don't beat yourself up for trusting them; these scam ops are designed to look legit and play on our desire for financial security. Keep documenting *everything*. Every email, every chat log, every invoice they send. That stuff will be crucial if you decide to report them.

Michael Moore · Phoenix, USAanswered 26d ago
5

A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? Seriously? That sounds like absolute nonsense. I've never heard of such a thing from a legitimate brokerage. They're just inventing fees to squeeze more money out of you. If they're not regulated by a reputable authority like the FCA or BaFin, you're already in risky territory. MAS in Singapore might not have jurisdiction over an offshore entity like this. I'd be very wary.

Maryam Ahmed · Dubai, UAEanswered 26d ago
3

Hang in there! This is a common tactic for these scam operations. They reel you in with promises of big money, then when you try to cash out, they invent fees. 'Profit and loss reconciliation' sounds like pure garbage meant to pressure you. Don't send them another penny. Try reporting them to the MAS even if they're offshore; sometimes they can issue warnings or share info with other regulators. Keep all your proof like the original poster said.

Sean Murphy · Galway, Irelandanswered 26d ago
4

Ugh, 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'. Sounds like they're just making it up as they go. FXChoice... never heard of them, but if they're not properly licensed by a body like ASIC here in Aus, it's dodgy. They probably told you to deposit more money, didn't they? That's usually what happens. They want to keep you depositing, not withdrawing. See if ASIC has any warnings out about them, though I doubt it if they're offshore.

William Jones · Adelaide, Australiaanswered 26d ago
6

STOP. Do not send them any more money. This is a textbook recovery scam. They create fake fees to avoid paying you. That 'reconciliation fee' is not a real thing in forex trading, especially from a regulated entity. The fact they're not licensed by a serious regulator (if they even are FXChoice, they could be impersonating) is the biggest clue. Check the MAS website for a warning list for Forex brokers. They may not regulate this specific company directly, but they might have warned about similar operations.

Michael du Plessis · Cape Town, South Africaanswered 26d ago
7

Same happened to me with a similar outfit. They called it something else, a 'capital gains tax'. Then it was a 'banking processing fee'. Always a new fee to 'release funds'. Never pay. They make up the numbers. I lost about $15k to OptionStarsGlobal two years ago. They even sent me fake trade reports. My advice? Cut your losses if you can, even if it means losing the last bit you sent. Trying to get it back is usually impossible and just costs more money.

Jonas Koch · Munich, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

Aiyo, this sounds exactly like the stories I've heard. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is some new BS. They aren't regulated properly if they're asking for this. Like the previous person said, OptionStarsGlobal did something similar. Please, please don't send them more money. If you're in Singapore, you can try reporting to MAS, though they might say they don't have jurisdiction. But reporting it is better than nothing. The key is these guys prey on people needing to ‘balance books’ for fake regulators.

Hui Goh · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
6

This is a very common scam tactic in the unregulated forex and CFD space. The structure you're describing, pressuring for more funds, then blocking withdrawals with invented fees, is a well-worn playbook. FXChoice, if it's the entity you think it is, is not regulated by major authorities. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fabrication. Your MAS in Singapore is your best bet for reporting, even if it's an offshore entity. They track these kinds of complaints. Look up the MAS 'Investor Alerts list'.

Mohammed Khan · Al Ain, UAEanswered 26d ago
4

My heart goes out to you. This sounds so familiar. I was in a similar situation a year ago with a broker called 'Global Trade FX'. They asked for a 'verification fee' the first time I tried to withdraw. Then it was a 'currency conversion tax'. Each time, a new, ridiculous fee. I eventually paid about $8k extra before I realised they were never going to let me withdraw anything. It ruined me financially and emotionally. I hope you can find a way out of this mess.

Lotte de Boer · The Hague, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
7

Warning! This is a scam. Do not pay any further fees. They are inventing them to steal your money. FXChoice is likely a scam operation, possibly an alias for another known scam. There is no such thing as a 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' required by regulators for an individual trader. They want your money. Block them, report them to MAS immediately. If you paid by credit card, see if you can do a chargeback. It's a long shot with forex, but worth trying.

Saar Mulder · Tilburg, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
3

Yeah, this is rough. I got hit with something similar, though not FXChoice specifically. They kept saying I needed to pay up to 'unlock' my profits. First it was taxes, then they said my account was flagged for 'money laundering' and I needed to pay a fee to clear it. It was all lies, of course. They just kept inventing reasons. I lost a few thousand dollars before I finally gave up. You're doing the right thing by questioning it.

Lucas Williams · Gold Coast, Australiaanswered 26d ago
5

Oh mate, that's a classic. 'Profit and Loss Reconciliation Fee' is a new one on me, but the playbook is ancient. Unregulated brokers, pressure to deposit, impossible withdrawal conditions. They're not regulated by anyone credible like the FCA or ASIC. It's designed to bleed you dry. I'd be very surprised if MAS can directly help with an offshore entity, but reporting it to them still creates a record. Keep records - they're gold.

Ava Walker · Darwin, Australiaanswered 26d ago
3

Singapore here too. Yeah, MAS might not have direct jurisdiction over an offshore broker, but they still want to know. File a complaint with them anyway. It helps them track patterns of fraud. They often have sections on their website about common scam types. What they're doing is definitely not right. These fees are just made up to keep you sending them money. Don't do it. I've seen friends lose money this way too.

Anna Jansen · Almere, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
4

This is horrible! My cousin went through something similar. They called it a 'compliance oversight fee' before they would release her winnings from a fake crypto platform. She ended up paying them nearly 10k more, and then they just vanished. She was devastated. She contacted the police and the financial regulator, but because it was offshore and they used crypto, there was little they could do. Try reporting to MAS, but be prepared that recovery might be tough.

Noor Al Mansoori · Dubai, UAEanswered 26d ago
5

I've seen this exact pattern before. The fake fees are designed to mimic legitimate procedures, but there's no actual requirement for them. The fact they are unregulated is the biggest indicator. Reporting it to your local MAS is the correct first step. They might not be able to recover the funds directly, but they can issue warnings and investigate potential fraud rings that involve local victims. Document everything; screenshots, emails, invoices, chat logs. Everything.

Khalid Sheikh · Ajman, UAEanswered 26d ago
7

YES. I faced this. With a broker based in Cyprus, not this one but same tactics. Called it an 'anti-money laundering verification fee.' Total rubbish. They said I had to pay 20% of my winnings to 'prove my funds weren't dirty.' I told my wife I wasn't paying it, she got really mad at me for losing the money in the first place. Eventually, I just walked away, losing what I'd sent them. It's a scam. Report them to MAS. They won't get your money back probably, but at least it might help others.

Grace Tan · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
4

This is a classic recovery scam. The fake fees are just made up. Don't send them another cent. They prey on people trying to get their money out. Your MAS is the correct place to report this. Make sure you mention the fake fees and the pressure tactics. Even if they don't have jurisdiction to recover your funds, they can add the broker to their warning list, which is crucial for protecting others.

Naledi Naidoo · East London, South Africaanswered 26d ago
6

My uncle fell for this exact thing last year, with a different broker but the same BS fees. They called it a 'regulatory adjustment fee'. He paid it, then they asked for another. He ended up losing almost his entire pension. He was absolutely devastated. He reported it to the police here, but they said it was too difficult to pursue offshore. Please, do not pay them anything more. Report it to MAS. It’s your only real recourse.

Olivia van der Merwe · Pretoria, South Africaanswered 26d ago
7

Oh mate, this sounds super similar to a few cases I've seen referred to the FCA. That whole 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a classic red flag for these shady offshore ops. They invent all sorts of nonsense charges to bleed you dry. FXChoice isn't regulated by any reputable body like the FCA or ASIC, so they can basically make up rules as they go.

Don't pay it. Seriously. You'll just end up paying more and more fees with no prospect of withdrawal. These places operate on a pure scam model. The only way to get money out is if you used a credit card for the initial deposit IF it's still within chargeback timeframes (unlikely by now, but check with your bank).

Charlotte Wilson · Melbourne, Australiaanswered 26d ago
4

This is exactly how they got me. They called it a 'compliance fee' after I asked for my money back. Then it was a 'transactional tax'. It's a merry-go-round of fake fees. I lost my house deposit to these vultures – OptionStarsGlobal, that was their name. They promised the moon. I was so ashamed and angry at myself. Haven't told my wife still. Still trying to figure out how to even get back on my feet. I reported them to the authorities but it felt like shouting into the void.

Sophie du Plessis · Johannesburg, South Africaanswered 26d ago
3

Profit and loss reconciliation fee? Sounds entirely made up. Why would a broker charge you a fee to 'reconcile' profits and losses? That's their job, and it's usually done internally. Or if there *is* tax involved, you pay that to the government, not the broker.

FXChoice -- are they even registered anywhere legit? I looked them up and didn't see any serious regulatory body listed, like BaFin or AMF. If they're not regulated, they can say anything. Next they'll want a 'server maintenance fee' or some other rubbish. Watch your wallet.

Adam Michel · Marseille, Franceanswered 26d ago
5

So sorry you're going through this, it sounds incredibly stressful. Don't beat yourself up too much, these scammers are very good at what they do.

That fee sounds like pure fiction. They're just trying to get more money from you. If you haven't already, document *everything*. Every email, every chat log, every deposit. That way, if you decide to report it (which you should, even if it feels pointless), you have a clear record.

Have you tried contacting your bank about a chargeback for those initial deposits? It's a long shot, especially if it was more than a few months ago, but worth a try.

Sem de Groot · The Hague, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
6

This is exactly the same tactic used against me by a scam broker last year. Unregulated outfit, based in Cyprus I think. They wanted an 'anti-money laundering fee' after I requested a withdrawal. Then a 'capital gains tax payment'. Never saw a penny back. I ended up losing £25k. My husband was furious. I just felt sick to my stomach. I filed a report with the FCA but they said since the broker wasn't registered with them, their hands were tied. It's devastating.

Sophie Hall · Glasgow, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
3

Oh, I feel this. I went through something really similar with another forex scam, 'GlobalFXPro' or something equally generic. They hit me with a 'withdrawal processing fee' and then a 'regulatory compliance charge'. In the end, they demanded something like 30% of my supposed profits to be wired to a personal bank account in Eastern Europe. Total garbage.

When I refused, they just deactivated my account. I'm in South Africa, and even though the FSCA has warnings out, it's hard to get traction when the money's already gone offshore. Took me nearly a year to get my head around it.

Tess de Groot · Almere, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
5

They promised me unrealistic returns too, like you. I put in €10k, which was all my savings from working double shifts for years. Then, when I wanted to withdraw, they said I had a 'tax liability' I needed to pay upfront. It felt so wrong. I paid it, and then they came back with another 'administrative fee'. I never got a cent back. They're just thieves. I'm in the Netherlands, and honestly, the AFM can't do much if these sites aren't registered here. It's a nightmare.

Mees de Jong · Eindhoven, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
4

Mate, this is textbook. If they're not regulated by a body like ASIC here in Australia, then they're pretty much operating outside the law. FXChoice is one of those offshore names that pops up periodically with these same stories. They invent fees as they go to string people along.

Here's the thing: a legitimate broker doesn't ask for fees to release your *own* money. Taxes are paid to the government, not to the broker. And reconciliation is their internal problem, not yours. Don't pay another cent.

Jack Thompson · Melbourne, Australiaanswered 26d ago
3

A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? That sounds absolutely made up. Brokers are supposed to be regulated by entities like the FSCA (if they operate here) or similar bodies abroad. They don't charge clients fees to *reconcile* things. That's their internal accounting.

If they keep demanding money, it's a scam. Period. Your best bet is to check if you can dispute the charges with your bank or credit card company, especially if the initial deposits were recent. It's unlikely to work if it's been a while, but it's your only real shot besides reporting it.

Sophie Naidoo · Durban, South Africaanswered 26d ago
6

This exact scenario is a well-documented type of advance-fee fraud, often seen with unregulated forex or crypto platforms. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fabricated charge designed to extract more money after you've already deposited funds. Legitimate brokers, regulated by authorities like the CFTC in the US or the FCA in the UK, do not operate this way.

Here's a key red flag: if a broker claims you need to pay a fee to release your *own* profits or capital, it's almost certainly a scam. Taxes are paid to tax authorities, and reconciliation is an internal process for the broker.

For reporting, while MAS in Singapore might have limited jurisdiction over offshore entities, you should still file a complaint with them and potentially the relevant financial crimes unit in the jurisdiction where FXChoice claims to be based, if that information is even accurate. Also, check with your bank about initiatiing a chargeback if possible.

Daniel Johnson · Phoenix, USAanswered 26d ago
3

It's a scam. Plain and simple. Happened to me with a crypto platform called 'CoinFusion Masters' – sounds similar, right? They wanted a 'withdrawal verification fee' after I'd made a decent profit. Then it was a 'network upgrade contribution'. My spouse was so mad at me for falling for it. I lost my savings. I'm still trying to rebuild. Just needed to vent, I guess. Reporting them felt so useless, like sending a postcard. They're gone now, probably rebranded.

Lucas White · Canberra, Australiaanswered 26d ago
4

Yeah, I've seen this one too. Not with FXChoice directly, but a very similar setup. An unregulated broker, based out of some island nation, pulled the same 'tax fee' and then a 'transfer fee' on me. I ended up losing about AUD $15,000. Felt like such an idiot, especially when I told my wife what happened. She was surprisingly supportive, thankfully, but still.

My main piece of advice? Assume any fee they ask for *after* you've deposited is a scam. Legit operations don't do that. They make money on spreads or commissions, not by demanding random fees to give you your money back. Report them to ASIC if you can, but honestly, it's a long shot.

Ling Koh · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
7

This is a very common advance-fee scam used by unregulated brokers. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is completely fabricated. It's designed to trick you into paying more money before they disappear. Reputable regulators like MAS, FCA, or BaFin would never allow a brokerage to operate this way.

When you encounter demands for fees to release funds, especially ones that sound like internal accounting or tax issues that you have to pay *to the broker*, definitely consider it a scam.

My advice: Do NOT pay the fee. Cease all communication with them. Then, report them to MAS and also to any consumer protection agencies in your country. Also, if you used a credit card for any deposits, contact your card issuer immediately to dispute the charges.

Felix Wolf · Dresden, Germanyanswered 26d ago
3

Argh, this makes my blood boil. They promised me the world too. I put in a few thousand Euros. Then bam! 'Tax fee'. Then another 'administrative fee'. I kept arguing with them, saying it didn't make sense. My girlfriend told me to just quit, but I thought I was so close to a big win. Lost it all. The broker was called 'Forex Elite Pro' – probably the same people. It's horrible. I still get nightmares about their dodgy website.

David Wilson · Denver, USAanswered 26d ago
5

This sounds exactly like a scam. A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is not a standard practice in legitimate financial markets. Brokers are regulated, and their regulatory responsibilities don't involve charging clients fees for their internal accounting. You should be extremely suspicious.

If FXChoice is not regulated by a reputable authority like the CFTC or FCA, they can invent any fee they want. This is a common tactic to get more money from victims. Don't pay it. Your next step should be to report them to the relevant financial authorities in Singapore (MAS) and potentially the US (CFTC), even if they are offshore. They maintain databases of scams.

Paul Weber · Leipzig, Germanyanswered 26d ago
4

Oh dear, this is horribly familiar. I lost a significant sum to a very similar scam a couple of years ago. They called it a 'verification fee' after I’d supposedly made a huge profit. Then it was a 'banking protocol charge.' My partner told me to stop, but I was blinded by the potential gains they showed me on my screen. It's gutting. I filed a complaint with BaFin, but they said the company wasn't registered with them. What a joke.

Jules Robert · Strasbourg, Franceanswered 26d ago
3

This is classic. They reel you in with promises of profit, then hit you with fake fees when you try to take your money out. I lost about £8,000 to a broker called 'Global TradeFX' last year. They wanted a 'capital gains tax payment' and then an 'international transfer fee.' The FCA has warnings out about many of these unregulated brokers, but it feels like a whack-a-mole game. I still can't look at my bank statement without feeling sick.

Harry Green · Edinburgh, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
5

Yes, this is a scam tactic. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is entirely made up. Brokers are regulated to prevent fraud, not to extort clients. Unregulated brokers like FXChoice often invent these arbitrary fees – tax clearance, compliance, reconciliation – to steal more money.

I fell for a similar scam. They wanted a 'security deposit' to release my funds. Lost my emergency savings. It's a brutal lesson. If you paid via credit card, contact your bank ASAP to start a chargeback. It's your best chance, even if it's a long shot.

Thabo Dlamini · Durban, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

Ugh, this makes me feel sick. This is exactly how they emptied my account. They called it a 'preventative anti-fraud tax' and then a 'blockchain verification fee.' It sounded so official, but it was all lies. I was devastated. I reported it to the FSCA, but they said much of this illegal activity happens offshore and it's hard to trace. I'm still trying to recover financially and emotionally.

Tess de Boer · The Hague, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
6

I'm so sorry you're going through this. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is definitely a scam. These unregulated brokers are trained to invent fees to keep you sending money. It's a classic advance-fee fraud.

If you paid using a credit card, immediately contact your credit card company and initiate a dispute for all the transactions. Explain that this was an unauthorized withdrawal demand from a fraudulent broker. This is often the only way to recover funds from these types of scams. Also, file a report with the MAS in Singapore and the relevant consumer protection agencies.

Lauren Martin · Minneapolis, USAanswered 26d ago
5

Oh mate, this screams scam. FXChoice? Never heard of them being legit. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a classic move. They invent some bureaucratic nonsense to keep you paying. They'll just invent another fee next. Standard procedure for these outfits when they think you've got more cash. Don't send them another penny. You need to report this.

Rachel Green · Liverpool, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

So sorry you're going through this. It sounds incredibly stressful. That fee sounds very suspicious, especially when they pushed you to invest more earlier. Singapore's MAS does have some powers for offshore entities that solicit investments *from* Singaporeans, even if the company itself is registered elsewhere. You might want to check their website for 'reporting scams' or 'unlicensed entities'. Keep all the communication records, it’s important proof.

Wei Wong · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
6

Run. Don't walk away. That's not a real fee. Anywhere. Especially not from a broker that's not properly regulated in a major jurisdiction like the UK (FCA), EU (BaFin/AFM), or Australia (ASIC). They just make it up to bleed you dry. Each new 'fee' is just another way to delay and extort. If you've paid them any money via credit card, dispute the charges immediately. Banks can sometimes claw back funds.

Emma Byrne · Belfast, Irelandanswered 26d ago
7

This is exactly what happened to me with a different outfit. 'Admin fee,' 'tax fee,' 'processing fee' — it never ends. They had me sending money to what looked like a legitimate business account, but it was all smoke and mirrors. I lost about $15k. I filed a report with the CFTC, but they said it was outside their jurisdiction since the company wasn't US-based. I feel so stupid and ashamed.

David Williams · Phoenix, USAanswered 26d ago
5

FXChoice, hmm? I've seen similar tactics before, usually with unregulated or offshore platforms. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is pure fabrication. Regulators don't work like that. They're likely trying to pressure you into paying more because they've seen you're willing to part with money. What I'd suggest is immediately ceasing all communication that involves sending them money. Verify the broker registration *before* depositing. Check official registers like ASIC's. This sounds like a Forex scam.

Charlotte Smith · Darwin, Australiaanswered 26d ago
5

This screams 'advance fee scam'. They've got your money, and now they're inventing reasons for you to send *more* money. It’s a common tactic used by scam brokers. The key is that they're asking for money *before* releasing funds, and the reason they give is arbitrary and sounds like jargon. A real broker wouldn't operate this way. Always check the regulatory status with the relevant authority in their stated country of origin. If they're not regulated by a reputable body like FCA, ASIC, etc., it's a massive red flag.

Isla Smith · Hobart, Australiaanswered 26d ago
6

Alert! This is a very common scam. They lure you in with promised profits, then invent fees to keep your money trapped. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds designed to confuse you. It's not a real thing in legitimate trading. Do NOT pay any more. Contact your bank immediately and see if you can recall the transactions, especially if they were recent credit card payments. Reporting to consumer protection agencies is also crucial, even if they're offshore.

Milan Visser · Nijmegen, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
7

I've been there. Lost about R80k to a broker that asked for similar 'fees' to supposedly clear my profits. They just kept asking for more, citing different 'regulations' each time. Eventually, my money was just gone. My advice? Stop talking to them. Report them to any financial ombudsman or regulator you can find, even if they're overseas. It's unlikely you'll get the money back, but telling the authorities might stop them from hurting someone else. I eventually reported mine to the IC3 in the US, but tbh, it felt like shouting into the void.

Emma Botha · Port Elizabeth, South Africaanswered 26d ago
5

Hmm, FXChoice. Sounds fishy. I've heard of brokers doing this, but usually they are quite obscure. If they are asking for fees *before* withdrawal, especially for something as nebulous as 'reconciliation,' I'd be extremely suspicious. Did you check if they are regulated by, say, BaFin or the FCA? If not, that's your biggest clue. They just want more money. Don't fall for it.

Stefan Schmidt · Berlin, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

That's a classic advance-fee scam. They create a fabricated reason for you to pay more money before they release 'your' funds. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is indeed just a made-up term to sound official. The real ones are regulated, and you can check their registry numbers on sites like the FCA's. If they pressure you for more money and use convoluted terms, walk away. Try reporting them to the FCA if they claim any UK link, or SG's MAS if they target Singaporeans.

Harry Wright · Glasgow, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
6

I feel your pain. This happened to me with OptionStarsGlobal. They kept saying I needed to pay capital gains tax first, then a 'withdrawal processing fee.' It was always something new. I eventually paid them almost $30k in total. I hope you haven't paid this new fee. I’m in the US and reported it to the FTC and my state's AG office, but they said there was little they could do for an offshore entity. I'm exploring chargebacks with my credit card company, but it's tough.

Samantha Allen · Minneapolis, USAanswered 26d ago
5

This is a well-known scam tactic, unfortunately. They create fictional fees to trap your money. The fact that they are asking for a 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' suggests they are trying to mimic legitimate financial processes to appear credible. Never pay upfront fees to release funds. Always verify the broker's regulatory status with bodies like MAS, FCA, or ASIC. If they are not regulated, it's a huge red flag.

Ahmed Sheikh · Al Ain, UAEanswered 26d ago
5

No, this is not a new scam tactic, it's an old one dressed up slightly differently. These brokers operate on a pure profit model: your loss is their gain, and if you somehow *do* see a profit, they invent reasons not to pay you. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is nonsense. They just want your cash. Stop sending them money. If you paid by credit card, contact your bank ASAP to dispute the charges. Most card issuers have fraud protection.

Daan Smit · Eindhoven, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
5

This scenario sounds incredibly familiar. Brokers that pressure you to invest more, then block withdrawals with invented fees like 'profit and loss reconciliation,' are almost certainly scams. They want to drain your account before you realize it's impossible to get money out. Your instinct is correct. Do not pay this fee. Check if FXChoice is registered with a reputable financial authority. If they aren't regulated by entities like the FCA, ASIC, or BaFin, then you have your answer. Report them.

Lucas van Dijk · Rotterdam, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
5

Absolutely, this is a scam. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is pure fabrication. Legit brokers don't operate like this. They'll keep inventing new fees until you either pay them more or give up. The key is that they are demanding payment *before* releasing *your* profits. Check the regulatory status of FXChoice with relevant bodies like the FCA (UK), ASIC (Australia), or BaFin (Germany). If they are not regulated, any money you send is likely lost.

Felix Neumann · Hannover, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

This specific scam is rampant. Unregulated brokers, especially those advertising high returns on crypto CFDs, often use these invented fees to keep your funds. They create documentation that looks official, but it's all fake. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is not a real requirement for withdrawals. Please do not send them any more money. Try reporting this to the relevant financial authority in the country where FXChoice claims to be based, or even to the MAS in Singapore if they solicited you there.

Hassan Al Mansoori · Sharjah, UAEanswered 26d ago
5

Yes, this is a scam. They're trying to get more money from you. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is made up. Don't pay it. If they are claiming to be a broker, check if they are registered with a reputable regulator like the FCA or ASIC. If they aren't, then they're operating illegally. It's likely you won't get your money back, but report them anyway.

Fatima Iqbal · Ras Al Khaimah, UAEanswered 26d ago
5

I'm so sorry you're dealing with this. It sounds exactly like a scam designed to take your money. That fee is definitely made up. Brokers like this prey on people's hope for high returns by making it impossible to withdraw when you actually want your cash. What I did when I was scammed was find out if the broker claimed to be regulated anywhere and report them. Even if they are offshore, agencies like the FCA or ASIC keep databases of known scam operations.

Fatima Al Maktoum · Dubai, UAEanswered 26d ago
6

Mate, I've seen this all before with online forex and crypto scams. They invent these ridiculous fees – 'tax clearance,' 'regulatory fee,' 'profit reconciliation.' It's all to keep your money. They'll just invent another reason if you pay this one. You need to cut your losses and stop sending them money ASAP. If you paid by credit card, try to get your bank to reverse the charges immediately. That's your best bet.

Conor O'Neill · Limerick, Irelandanswered 26d ago
5

This is textbook advance-fee fraud. They claim you owe a fee to release your funds, but the fee is completely fabricated. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is not a real concept in legitimate financial regulation for customer withdrawals. Your best bet is always to check the regulatory status of any firm *before* investing. If FXChoice isn't registered with a body like BaFin, FCA, or ASIC, it’s a major red flag. Do not pay them any more money. Report them to the MAS and any international scam reporting bodies.

Maximilian Bauer · Frankfurt, Germanyanswered 26d ago
12

Ah, the old 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'. Classic. This is a textbook advance-fee scam, often used by unregulated or outright fraudulent brokers. FXChoice itself has a pretty bad reputation online, fwiw. They'll keep inventing fees until you either pay them a fortune or realize it's a dead end. The invoice likely looks legitimate but it's just more digital theatre to convince you.

Seriously, stop sending them money. Anything they tell you about regulators or balancing books is a lie. There is no reconciliation fee to 'release' profits. This is pure fiction designed to extract more cash.

Your best bet, sadly, is to file a chargeback with your bank or credit card company IMMEDIATELY if you paid that way. Time is critical here.

Sophie Ryan · Belfast, Irelandanswered 26d ago
8

Oh no, this sounds awful. I'm so sorry you're going through this stress. Losing savings is terrifying, and dealing with these kinds of 'fees' just adds insult to injury.

It definitely sounds like a scam tactic. They create these fabricated problems to get more money from you before they just disappear. Don't send them any more.

I don't have much experience with offshore brokers, but I know the MAS in Singapore is usually good with financial complaints. Even if it's offshore, reporting it might create a record. You're definitely not alone in facing this sort of thing.

Emily Wilson · Cardiff, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
10

This screams scam. Wake up, please. FXChoice is not a legitimate broker, and these 'fees' are made up out of thin air. They want your money, and they are good at playing psychological games to get it.

'Profit and loss reconciliation fee'? For regulators? That's a load of rubbish. If they were regulated by, say, the FCA or BaFin, there would be strict rules about profit distribution, not arbitrary fees for 'reconciliation'.

Forget about 'balancing the books'. Your only real chance of seeing any of that money again is if you can do a chargeback through your credit card company. Don't pay another cent.

Noah Smit · The Hague, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
5

Honestly, this sounds like every scam broker story I've ever heard. They lure you in with fake profits, then hit you with a wall of fees when you try to get your cash out. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds completely made up.

Check if you paid via credit card. If so, call your bank and start a chargeback process like, yesterday. That's usually the only way to get anything back from these sharks. Good luck man, really hope you get something back.

Sean Ryan · Waterford, Irelandanswered 26d ago
11

Warning: This is a classic progression of a broker scam. First, they pressure you to deposit more, then introduce 'taxes' or 'fees' when you try to withdraw. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is designed to sound official and complex, making you think it's a legitimate regulatory requirement. It is not.

FXChoice has been flagged by multiple user forums as a scam operation. They are likely unlicensed and operating offshore specifically to avoid regulatory oversight. Any documentation they send, including invoices, is likely fabricated.

Do NOT send them any more money. Your next step should be to contact your bank or credit card provider immediately to report the transactions as fraudulent and attempt a chargeback. This is your most viable option to recover funds.

Eva van Dijk · Eindhoven, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
13

I've been there. Lost a fair bit to a similar setup a few years back, though it wasn't FXChoice. It was OptionStarsGlobal – same game, different name. They hit me with a 'compliance fee' after I 'made' a killing trading forex. Told me I needed to pay it to verify my account for withdrawal.

It's all a lie to get more of your money. They'll invent fee after fee. You're right to be suspicious. Don't pay it. Seriously. The best thing you can do is try a chargeback via your credit card company. Act fast, they have time limits.

Grace Harris · Brisbane, Australiaanswered 26d ago
15

This is precisely how these scam operations work. They create a fictional scenario, complete with made-up fees and official-looking documents, to pressure victims. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fabrication. Legitimate brokers do not operate this way.

Given that FXChoice seems to be unregulated and operating offshore, your options for recovery through official channels like the MAS (even if they could act) are limited. Your primary route should be financial.

Actionable Tip: If you funded your account via credit card, contact your card issuer IMMEDIATELY. Explain the situation and formally dispute the charges as fraudulent. Many credit card companies offer protection against such scams. This is your best and likely only chance.

Thomas Hughes · Birmingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
9

Echoing what others have said, this is a common scam. I'm sorry you're in this situation. The fees are just made up to bleed you dry. FXChoice is a known name in the scam broker lists online.

Since you're in Singapore, MAS likely won't be able to help directly with a dispute against an offshore entity, but reporting them to MAS anyway is a good idea for their records. You can find their complaint forms on the MAS website.

But the most practical advice here is to check your payment method. If it was a credit card, get that chargeback initiated ASAP. Time is of the essence with chargebacks.

Joshua Koh · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
14

Yep, I fell for something very similar a couple of years ago. Different broker, but the tactics were identical. Started small, got pressured to deposit more, then BOOM – withdrawal blocked by some bogus fee. Mine was called an 'anti-money laundering verification fee'. Sounded official, right? It wasn't.

They'll keep inventing them. Stop paying. What I did in the end was notify my bank and start the chargeback process. Took a few months, but I got most of it back because I used my Visa. If you paid by bank transfer... good luck, it's much harder then.

Cian Doyle · Cork, Irelandanswered 26d ago
6

Hmmm, 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'... that doesn't sound right at all. Fwiw, I've used brokers regulated by the FCA and BaFin, and never encountered anything like that. They have very specific withdrawal processes, but they don't involve paying extra fees to access your own money, especially not for 'reconciliation'.

If FXChoice is unregulated, then they can literally make up any story they want. It's a way to get more money from you. I'd be very hesitant to send them anything else. Did you check if they are on any scam warning lists?

Louise Thomas · Lille, Franceanswered 26d ago
12

This is incredibly common with offshore, unregulated brokers. They operate outside the reach of most financial regulators, so they can invent any excuse to keep your money. FXChoice is widely reported as a scam. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is just another manufactured obstacle.

They want you to keep paying, hoping you'll eventually give up or pay them enough that it's not worth fighting for the rest. Don't fall for it. Report the fraud to your bank and try to initiate a chargeback if you used a credit card. That's your most realistic path to recovery.

Jessica Anderson · Chicago, USAanswered 26d ago
16

I work in the industry, and I can tell you that 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is not a standard or recognized fee within legitimate financial brokerage operations. It sounds like a complete fabrication. Regulated entities like those under the FCA, CFTC, or even BaFin have transparent fee structures and withdrawal policies. Any mention of such a fee is a massive red flag.

FXChoice is known in the forums for these kinds of tactics. They are likely unlicensed and unregulated. The best course of action is to cease all communication and immediately contact your bank or credit card company to file a dispute for fraudulent activity. Act swiftly, as chargeback windows can be short. Reporting them to relevant authorities, like the FCA if they claim any UK connection, might also be worthwhile, though recovery is unlikely through them.

Hannah Wood · Edinburgh, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
7

Oh, that sounds awful. That 'fee' sounds completely made up. I've never heard of that from any proper broker, whether regulated by the FCA or not. My cousin lost money to a dodgy crypto platform last year, and they also tried to hit him with fake fees for withdrawals. He ended up reporting it to his bank and managed to get his money back through a chargeback. Definitely check if you paid by card and try that route. Don't send them any more money, it's just fuel for their fire.

Henry Wilson · Sheffield, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
10

Seriously? A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? That sounds like something they just invented. I've dealt with a few brokers over the years, some regulated, some not, and never once have I heard of that. It's always some new excuse when you try to get your money out.

If you paid by credit card, call your bank. NOW. Tell them it's a scam. They have processes for this. If you paid by wire transfer... man, that’s tough. They essentially have your money and are just playing games. Don't send them more. It’s over.

Paul Richter · Munich, Germanyanswered 26d ago
8

I'm really sorry to hear this. It sounds like a very stressful situation. It's good that you're questioning the fee – your gut feeling is probably right. Many people have been targeted by similar scams where brokers invent fees to prevent withdrawals.

While MAS might not be able to directly intervene with an offshore entity, reporting them to MAS is still a good step for their records and to warn others. Your ABSOLUTE best bet for trying to recover funds is a chargeback via your credit card provider if you used one. The faster you act, the better your chances.

Yusuf Ahmed · Al Ain, UAEanswered 26d ago
13

This makes my blood boil. This is exactly the kind of predatory behaviour I experienced with a scam broker before. They'll keep inventing these ridiculous fees – 'regulatory compliance', 'account maintenance', 'profit tax', and now 'profit and loss reconciliation'. It's pure theatre to deny you your funds.

FXChoice is known for this. They prey on people's desire for quick profits. Do not pay them another cent. Your best option is to immediately contact your bank or credit card company and initiate a chargeback. Gather all your transaction records, emails, and any 'invoices' they sent you. This is your only real hope.

Lea Lefebvre · Strasbourg, Franceanswered 26d ago
11

This is 100% a scam. That ‘profit and loss reconciliation fee’ is completely fabricated. Legitimate brokers do not require such payments to release profits. They're trying to squeeze more money out of you before they disappear. FXChoice has a known reputation for these types of fraudulent activities.

Your best avenue for recovery, especially since they are offshore and likely unregulated, is to contact your bank or credit card issuer immediately. If you used a credit card, initiate a chargeback. This is the most effective way to dispute fraudulent transactions. Don’t send them any more money, as it will only enable their scam.

Lucas Simon · Nice, Franceanswered 26d ago
10

This is textbook. I unfortunately lost a few grand to a broker like this. They called it a 'liquidity adjustment fee' after I tried to pull out my winnings. Sounded so official. They sent me fake looking documents and everything. It's all a lie to get you to pay more.

Stop sending them money! Seriously. The only thing you can try now is to go to your bank or credit card company and dispute the charges. You have to act fast though, there are time limits on how far back they can look for chargebacks. Good luck, this is a rough one.

Saar van Dijk · Groningen, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
12

Oh goodness, that sounds utterly dreadful. I'm so sorry you're dealing with this kind of thing. It's a horrible feeling when you realise you might have been scammed. That ‘profit and loss reconciliation fee’ sounds completely made up. It’s like they’re just inventing reasons to keep your money.

FXChoice is not a regulated broker, and these kinds of fees are their usual tactic. You're right to be suspicious. Please, for your own sake, don't send them any more money. Your best hope now is to contact your bank if you used a credit card for the initial deposit and try to initiate a chargeback. It’s your only real shot at getting any of that money back.

Chloe Naidoo · Port Elizabeth, South Africaanswered 26d ago
5

Ah, the 'profit and loss reconciliation fee.' Classic. This is a well-worn scam tactic, especially with unregulated brokers preying on crypto CFD traders. They just invent fees out of thin air. FXChoice, frankly, has a reputation that's less than stellar. They don't hold proper licenses in major jurisdictions like Europe or Australia. This invoice they sent? Likely a fake document to lend false legitimacy. Reporting to the MAS in Singapore might not get your money back directly, as they're offshore, but it does help build a case if they ever try to operate in a regulated space again. Always check for regulatory body approval *before* depositing funds. You can usually search the regulator's website directly.

Sem de Vries · Almere, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
4

Oh wow, that sounds incredibly stressful. I'm really sorry you're going through this. It's completely understandable why you'd be worried. That fee sounds really suspect, especially after they initially asked for a 'tax clearance fee.' Those initial promises of high returns can be so tempting, but when it comes to getting your own money back, it can become a nightmare. Don't beat yourself up about it, these scams are designed to look legit. Wishing you the best of luck getting this sorted.

Thomas Brown · Perth, Australiaanswered 26d ago
5

Mate, I hate to say it, but this smells heavily of a scam. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' isn't a real thing in legitimate trading. Brokers don't demand fees like that to release your own funds. They're just trying to squeeze more money out of you. FXChoice itself is known to be problematic – definitely not regulated by the FCA here in the UK or by ASIC in Australia. If you deposited using a credit card, you might have a small chance with a chargeback, but it's time-limited. Don't send them another cent. This is how they reel you in, then drain you.

William Walker · Sydney, Australiaanswered 26d ago
6

Been there. Twice. I lost about $8k to a similar setup with OptionStarsGlobal a couple years ago. They hit me with a 'withdrawal tax' and then a 'compliance fee'. Exactly the same story. It's gutting, I know. Felt like an idiot for weeks. The key thing is they *want* you to pay that fee. They'll keep inventing them until you run out of money or realize it's a scam. My friend who's a lawyer advised me to just chalk it up as a hard lesson learned and report them to wherever I could. I reported them to the CFTC, though I never heard back. They're long gone now, of course. Good luck, hope you have better luck than me.

Jason Anderson · Chicago, USAanswered 26d ago
4

A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? That sounds... made up. Like, if you're a massive institutional player with complex derivatives, maybe there's some obscure back-office reconciliation, but not for retail traders demanding their own cash. And FXChoice? I've never heard of them being regulated by anyone reputable. If you dealt with them, it's likely you are not dealing with a legit entity. I'd be very hesitant to pay anything further. Could you check your bank or credit card provider to see if there's any recourse there? Sometimes they have fraud departments that can help if it was recent.

Sophia Fortin · Montreal, Canadaanswered 26d ago
3

Oh dear, that sounds like a typical advance-fee scam. I am very sorry to hear this is happening to you. It's so unsettling when you're trying to access your own money and these hurdles appear. Please don't blame yourself; these fraudsters are very good at making things look legitimate, sending fake invoices and all. A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is not a standard procedure for legitimate brokers. If you haven't already, check if FXChoice is regulated by BaFin or another EU authority. It's doubtful, but worth a quick look. Keep all communication records. That might be useful later.

Leon Becker · Hamburg, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

This is textbook. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a classic move from scam brokers. They invent these arbitrary charges to justify keeping your money. FXChoice isn't regulated by the FCA, that's a huge red flag. Legitimate brokers don't ask for extra fees to release your profits. They might charge you for withdrawal processing, which is usually a small fixed amount or a percentage, but not this kind of invented fee. If you paid via bank transfer, recovery is near impossible. If it was a credit card, you *might* have some luck with a chargeback, but it's a long shot, especially if it's been a while. Consider reporting them to the FCA anyway for their records, even if they don't operate directly here.

Rachel Walker · Glasgow, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
6

Hi there. I'm based in Singapore too and I've seen similar stories. Unfortunately, the MAS does regulate financial institutions here, but if FXChoice is truly offshore and not registered with them, their power is limited. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is definitely a nonsense charge. They are trying to scare you into paying more. Don't do it. I'd suggest you immediately report them to the MAS anyway, and also see if any consumer protection agencies are active against offshore scams. Keep copies ofEVERYTHING. Even if they can't get your money back directly, reporting helps others.

Rachel Ng · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
4

Ach, the same thing happened to me last year, though with a different broker. They were called OptionStarsGlobal, total scam. First it was a 'verification fee', then a 'training tax' (I never had any training!), and then yes, a 'p&l reconciliation fee'. It’s so frustrating because they make it sound official, like a real invoice. I ended up losing about €6,000 this way. I just stopped communicating. I figured if I paid that fee, they'd just invent another one. My suggestion? Cut your losses if you can't get the money out, and report them everywhere you can think of. It's a tough lesson, but better than losing more.

Marie Muller · Hannover, Germanyanswered 26d ago
3

I'm so sorry you're in this situation. It sounds absolutely terrifying, and I can only imagine the stress. I was in a similar position about 8 months ago with a different broker who also promised the moon. They kept asking for more money for different 'fees' – a 'security deposit', then a 'withdrawal processing fee'. I ended up losing a good chunk of my savings, close to $15k. I felt so stupid and ashamed. I never got any of it back. I reported it to the FCA, but they have no jurisdiction over offshore companies. Don't send them more money. Please. I hope somehow you can get it back.

Amelia Green · Nottingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
5

This fee structure, the 'profit and loss reconciliation fee', is a huge indicator of a scam. Legitimate brokers, like those regulated by BaFin or the FCA, operate under strict guidelines. They don't randomly invent fees to release client funds. This sounds like a classic advance-fee fraud. They've lured you in, encouraged you to deposit more, and now they're preventing withdrawal by making up bogus charges. I highly recommend you stop all communication with FXChoice immediately and *do not* send them any more money. Report them to the MAS, and also consider filing a complaint with your card issuer if you used a credit/debit card.

Maximilian Schmidt · Dresden, Germanyanswered 26d ago
6

This is exactly how it starts. I lost over $20,000 to a broker that used these same tactics. First, it was a small 'admin fee' to verify my account, then a 'tax payment' which they said was required by their 'regulators'. Then came the 'liquidity transfer fee' and finally, the 'profit reconciliation fee'. They sent me official-looking PDFs too, complete with fake logos. I eventually realized they were never going to let me withdraw anything. I stopped paying and reported them to the CFTC, but honestly, I think most of that money is gone forever. It's a brutal lesson. The fact that FXChoice isn't licensed by a major regulator like the FCA or ASIC is your biggest clue.

Emily Wright · Glasgow, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
5

Good question. A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is not a standard concept in retail forex or CFD trading. It sounds like they're trying to create a fabricated reason to keep your funds. The fact that FXChoice is unregulated in major jurisdictions, and you've already been asked for a 'tax clearance fee', points strongly towards a scam. MAS can help if the company has any presence or registration in Singapore, but if it's purely offshore, their direct power is limited. Your best bet is to check if you paid by credit card and initiate a chargeback with your bank. Highlight these suspicious, invented fees as the reason for the dispute.

Sipho Smit · Pretoria, South Africaanswered 26d ago
5

My friend, I read this and my heart sank. I experienced something very similar with a fraudulent outfit posing as a forex broker. They invented a 'capital gains tax' and then a 'withdrawal processing fee'. It’s a common script for these scammers. The more you question, the more fees they invent. Please, do not send them any more money. It will just disappear. FXChoice is known in scam forums. If you paid by credit card, contact your bank IMMEDIATELY and initiate a chargeback. Mention these invented fees. It's your best shot at recovering any funds, though time is critical.

Rachel Yeo · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
6

This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is total rubbish. It's not a legitimate charge. FXChoice is an unregulated entity and this is a common scam tactic called an advance-fee fraud. They'll keep asking for more money, inventing new fees, until you can't pay anymore. Reporting to MAS is a good idea, but since they are offshore, recovery is very difficult. Check if you paid using a credit card. If so, contact your bank and start a chargeback process. Provide them with all the evidence of the fake fees and communication. Also, be wary of 'recovery scams' that might contact you claiming they can get your money back for a fee – that's another scam.

Khalid Al Marri · Abu Dhabi, UAEanswered 26d ago
3

I understand your distress. It’s a horrible situation to be in. That fee sounds highly irregular. In my experience as someone following the markets, legitimate brokers regulated by bodies like the FCA or ASIC will not ask for such arbitrary fees to release your funds. They have clear fee structures for trades and withdrawals. If FXChoice is indeed unregulated, they are likely operating a scam. I would advise against paying this fee. Instead, you could try checking with your local consumer protection agency or even law enforcement, though success is unlikely with offshore entities. Keep all evidence safe.

Lina Simon · Paris, Franceanswered 26d ago
5

Okay, hold up. A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'?? That is almost certainly a fabrication. I've traded with real brokers, regulated entities like those overseen by BaFin, and never once encountered such a thing. They want to bleed you dry. FXChoice is notorious for this kind of scam. They are not regulated. It's your money, and they have no right to hold it hostage with fake fees. Don't pay it. If you paid by credit card, that's your best avenue for recovery, try to get a chargeback. Otherwise, it's very difficult.

Amelia Clark · Brighton, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

This sounds EXACTLY like the scam that cost me $10k last year with a crypto broker. They hit me with a 'compliance fee', then a 'national tax clearance fee', before finally landing on the 'profit withdrawal fee'. It's always something new to get more money. My mistake was paying the first couple of fees because they looked so official. Don't do it. FXChoice is not a regulated broker. You can check the MAS website for licensed entities – they won't be on it. Your best hope is a credit card chargeback or, sadly, accepting it as a hard lesson learned.

Aaron Tay · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
5

Wow, this is a classic advance-fee scam I've seen mentioned frequently. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a made-up charge designed to confuse you and extort more money. FXChoice is an unregulated entity, and these kinds of brokers thrive on these fabricated fees. Don't send them another cent. Reporting to MAS might seem like the right step, but if they're truly offshore, MAS's reach is limited for direct recovery. Your best bet is to see if a credit card chargeback is possible. If you paid via wire transfer, recovery is extremely unlikely. Keep all documentation – it might be useful if a recovery agency ever surfaces, though be wary of those too.

Liam Coetzee · East London, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

This sounds like trouble, plain and simple. That 'fee' is not a real thing in legitimate trading. Legitimate brokerages regulated by authorities like the FCA or CFTC don't invent fees to hold your money. They have clear terms. FXChoice likely has no real regulation, which is the biggest red flag. If you paid by credit card, contact your bank immediately to dispute the charges. Explain that the broker is demanding fraudulent fees to release your funds. It's your best chance, but act fast. Don't pay any more money to these people.

Daniel Quinn · Galway, Irelandanswered 26d ago
2

This is a classic pattern for unregulated brokers, especially those dealing in CFDs and crypto. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is almost certainly fabricated. Unregulated platforms often invent fees like this to trap victims. FXChoice, based on online reports, operates without proper licensing in major jurisdictions. Your MAS (Monetary Authority of Singapore) might not have direct recourse if the entity is offshore and not registered with them, but you should still report it. File a complaint with MAS and also consider reporting to the financial crime unit in your country. The invoice is likely a digital forgery too.

Layla Al Nahyan · Abu Dhabi, UAEanswered 26d ago
1

Oh god, this sounds EXACTLY like what happened to me with OptionStarsGlobal a few years back. They started with these made-up fees too, first a 'withdrawal fee', then an 'admin processing charge' which was like 20% of my supposed profits. I paid it, like an idiot. Then they hit me with a 'compliance fee'. I never saw a dime back. I learned the hard way that if they ask for *any* money to get *your own* money out, it's game over. Don't pay them another cent. File a police report and see if your local financial regulator has a fraud division.

Maryam Al Falasi · Sharjah, UAEanswered 26d ago
3

User, be extremely wary. This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' smells very strongly of a scam. Regulated brokers like those overseen by the FCA don't operate this way. You wouldn't be asked to pay extra fees to 'reconcile' profits before withdrawal. It's a common tactic for illegitimate operations to invent obstacles and charges after you've deposited funds. They are likely never going to let you withdraw anything. Your best bet might be to dispute any transactions made via credit card if possible, though bank transfers are harder to recover. Also, report them to the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) here in the UK; they maintain a warning list of unauthorized firms.

Edward Jones · Glasgow, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
1

That sounds incredibly stressful, I'm really sorry you're going through this. It's completely understandable you're worried. I haven't experienced this specific fee with FXChoice, but I have heard similar stories from other platforms. What you're describing is a classic red flag for a scam. My advice, based on what others have shared, is to stop all communication with them about paying more money. Gather all your documentation – emails, transaction records, their invoices – and look up the official reporting channels for financial scams in Singapore, like MAS. Sometimes, just reporting it can help others even if recovery is difficult.

Sem Mulder · Groningen, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
2

This is textbook. I went through almost the exact same thing with a broker called 'Global Trade Solutions' last year. They wanted a 'tax verification fee,' then a 'network processing charge.' I ended up losing about $15k of my savings. They even sent me fake-looking documents that mimicked official government letters. My bank said since it was a transfer, they couldn't do much. I reported it to the CFTC as well, but honestly, the money is gone. The best advice I can give is to NEVER pay another fee. If they're asking for more money, the scam is just continuing. I'm so sorry, it's a horrible feeling.

Edward Harris · Nottingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
1

Ah, the fake fees. I know them well. I was caught by a similar scheme a few years ago, not FXChoice but another one that promised the moon. They asked for a 'validation fee' to release my small profits. I thought it was weird, but decided to pay it because I was so excited to get *something* back. Then came the 'currency conversion tax fee.' That's when I realized it was a complete scam. They eventually just disappeared. I reported them to BaFin, but recovery was impossible. Lesson learned: never pay money to get your money out. If you can, check if the original payment was via credit card and initiate a chargeback.

Laura Becker · Leipzig, Germanyanswered 26d ago
3

This sounds like a classic investment scam. 'FXChoice' is not a name I recognize as a legitimate, regulated broker. The fees they are inventing are meant to exploit your desire to get your money back and pressure you into paying more. Once they have got enough money, they will simply vanish or block you. There's very little chance of recovering funds sent via bank transfer once they're gone. Your best course of action is to report them to MAS in Singapore and be prepared for the unfortunate reality that recovering the money might be impossible. Never send them another penny. For anyone else reading: always, always verify a broker's regulatory status with the relevant authorities *before* depositing funds.

Amanda Lee · Denver, USAanswered 26d ago
1

Hang in there, it’s a horrible situation. This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is pure invention. I fell for a similar story with a binary options platform. They gave me a fake 'account manager' who kept telling me I needed to pay 'regulatory fees' to 'unlock' my account. First it was a small amount, then it climbed. I ended up paying nearly three grand extra before I got wise. They just kept making up new charges. I never got my money back. Report them to MAS for sure. Also, search for forex or CFD scam recovery groups online – sometimes people share useful advice, though be careful of recovery scammers too.

Thomas Hoffmann · Hannover, Germanyanswered 26d ago
1

Ah, the dance of the fake fees. Been there. It’s a rubbish feeling when you realise you’ve been had. I lost a good few quid on a crypto thing a while back when they brought out a 'capital gains tax clearance' charge after I asked to withdraw. Sounded legit, right? WRONG. Turned out to be pure guff. Don't pay them, OP. Whatever you do, don't send them any more money. Gather all the evidence you have and report it to MAS. You can also report it to the Singapore Police Force's' commercial affairs department. It’s unlikely you’ll get the money back, but reporting it helps authorities track these crooks.

Jack Smith · Cork, Irelandanswered 26d ago
2

This is a very common modus operandi for scam brokers operating outside of regulatory oversight. The fees are entirely fabricated. FXChoice is known to be an unregulated entity and likely targets individuals with promises of high returns. In Singapore, while MAS regulates financial institutions operating *within* Singapore, they also maintain alert lists for entities that may be targeting Singaporeans. You should absolutely report this to MAS. You can also check if the initial deposit was made via a credit card, in which case a chargeback might be a slim possibility. However, for wire transfers, recovery is exceedingly difficult. A key piece of advice for everyone: always check the regulatory registration of any financial firm with bodies like the FCA, BaFin, or ASIC *before* transferring funds.

Hannah Chan · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
1

Don't pay it. Seriously, whatever you do, don't pay that fee. This is a known scam tactic. They invented 'fees' constantly when I was with OptionStarsGlobal. First it was a 'transfer fee', then a 'server maintenance fee,' then 'legalisation fee.' Each time they asked for more money, it was just deeper into the hole. I eventually lost about $10k. I reported them to the AFM (Netherlands regulator), but it was a lost cause. They just vanished. I wish I'd never sent them my details. You need to report this to MAS and the police.

Niklas Hoffmann · Frankfurt, Germanyanswered 26d ago
1

Oh no, this sounds dreadfully familiar. I lost a fair bit to a broker that did exactly this. They claimed I owed a 'stamp duty fee' to release my winnings. I was so angry and stressed, I actually paid it. Big mistake. Then they wanted a 'commission transfer fee.' It never ended. I never got my money back. You need to stop communication immediately and report them to MAS. Also, check if your bank has any fraud protection. It's a long shot after bank transfers, but worth asking. This 'profit and loss reconciliation' is total nonsense.

Mei Chua · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
2

This is a common scam. They invent fees to get more money from you after you've already deposited. I lost $5,000 this way to a broker that also claimed to have high returns. They asked for a 'currency exchange fee' and then a 'compliance fee.' I paid both. They assured me my funds would be released. They never were. I reported it to the CFTC but they couldn't help. There’s unfortunately very little recourse once money is transferred. For others reading: always check if the broker is regulated by a reputable authority like the FCA or CFTC before you deposit any money.

Noah Bouchard · Winnipeg, Canadaanswered 26d ago
1

I'm so sorry you're going through this. It's a very common scam tactic. Brokers like these will invent any fee imaginable to keep you depositing. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is just another made-up charge. I lost a significant amount myself to a similar scheme a couple of years ago – they tried to get me to pay a 'capital gains tax' and then a 'regulatory clearance fee.' I never paid the second one and eventually they just stopped responding. My advice: do NOT pay them any more money. Report them to MAS. Your local police might also take a report for fraud. Get all your comms and statements together. It's unlikely you'll recover the funds, but reporting is important.

Thabo Smit · East London, South Africaanswered 26d ago
1

Ugh, this sounds like the nightmare I went through last year. They wanted a 'transactional audit fee' from me after I tried to withdraw my small profits. I panicked and paid it. Then they wanted a 'banking facilitation charge.' I finally realized it was a scam and stopped paying. They blocked me. Lost $8k. I reported it to the South African Reserve Bank, but they said they couldn't do anything as the broker was offshore. The best advice I can give anyone: NEVER pay a fee to withdraw funds from an unregulated broker. Report to MAS and the Singapore Police.

Fatima Al Marri · Al Ain, UAEanswered 26d ago
1

This is infuriating. I also got caught by a similar broker. They demanded a 'legal fee' to process my withdrawal. I was suspicious but they sounded so convincing. I paid it, and then they asked for a 'security deposit fee.' That was the final straw. I didn't pay it, and they refused to release my funds. They are probably operating completely illegally. Report them to MAS in Singapore. If you paid by credit card, try to do a chargeback. Otherwise, recovery is very difficult.

Maximilian Muller · Dresden, Germanyanswered 26d ago
1

This is textbook scam behavior. I encountered a very similar situation with a broker not too long ago. They demanded a 'compliance fee' and then an 'anti-money laundering fee' before they would release my funds, which were only a few thousand dollars but felt like a fortune to me at the time. I refused to pay more, and they simply ghosted me. I reported them to BaFin, but recovery seems impossible with these offshore outfits. The key thing to remember is that legitimate brokers don't ask for fees *to release your own funds*. Ever. Report this to MAS and the police. Warn everyone you know about this broker.

Felix Fischer · Berlin, Germanyanswered 26d ago
1

No, this is not a new tactic, it's an old, dirty one. I lost about 7 grand to a similar operation a couple of years ago. They started with a 'withdrawal processing fee', then, when I pushed back, they conjured up a 'capital gains tax reconciliation fee'. Sounded official, didn't it? It wasn't. They just wanted more of my money. My advice, from bitter experience: Do not send them any more money. Report them to MAS and the police. You can also try reporting them to consumer protection agencies in countries where they might have registered entities, though it's a long shot.

Stefan Schulz · Dresden, Germanyanswered 26d ago
1

The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is definitely a scam. I had a broker try to hit me with a 'server upgrade fee' and then a 'data verification charge' just last month when I tried to pull out my initial deposit. I refused to pay. They then tried to scare me with threatening messages about regulatory action against my account. It was all bluster. They eventually just stopped replying. It's frustrating, but don't pay them. Go straight to MAS and file a report. Also, check the broker's website for any listed regulatory bodies – if they claim to be regulated by someone like the FCA or ASIC, you can verify that on the regulator's actual website.

Laura Wolf · Frankfurt, Germanyanswered 26d ago
1

This sounds exactly like the scam I fell for with OptionStarsGlobal. They wanted a 'tax clearance fee' and then a 'transfer fee.' I ended up paying about $5,000 more before realizing they would never release my funds. It's a predatory tactic. They prey on people's hope. I reported them to the AFM, but it was useless. You need to report FXChoice to MAS. Also, if you made any payments via credit card, contact your card issuer immediately to try and initiate a chargeback. It's your best chance, though often difficult with offshore brokers.

Maryam Al Nahyan · Dubai, UAEanswered 26d ago
5

Oh mate, this sounds like the classic un unregulated broker scam. FXChoice is known for this specific tactic. That "profit and loss reconciliation fee"? Total fabrication. They want to squeeze more money out of you before they ghost you. It's a known red flag with these fake platforms. You absolutely should NOT pay it. It won't get you closer to your money, only further away.

Singapore's MAS *does* have a scam alert section on their website, worth checking, but yes, offshore is tricky. If they aren't regulated by a major body like the FCA, BaFin, or ASIC, getting your money back is near impossible. I'd start by reporting them to IC3 in the US, even if you're not there. They track these internationally.

Thomas Taylor · Manchester, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
3

I experienced something almost IDENTICAL with OptionStarsGlobal last year. They kept asking for 'verification fees' and then 'withdrawal fees'. By the time they asked for a 'compliance fee' I knew it was a scam. They even sent me a fake 'regulatory approval' document. I lost about 8k euros. It felt like a physical punch to the gut. I wish I'd seen your post sooner. Ngl, the thought of getting that money back is long gone for me. Just sharing so others can see the pattern.

Emma Muller · Dresden, Germanyanswered 26d ago
4

This is a very common scam. They create fake fees to keep you sending money. There is no such thing as a "profit and loss reconciliation fee" for the client to pay. This is designed to look 'official' with their invoices and fake regulatory jargon. Be very careful. Do not send them any more money. In the UAE, we have the SCA, but they regulate licensed entities. These offshore scam sites operate outside this. Your best bet is to report them to the authorities where *they* claim to be licensed. If they say they are regulated by the FCA in the UK or ASIC in Australia, report them there.

Ahmed Al Hashemi · Abu Dhabi, UAEanswered 26d ago
2

Hmm, 'FXChoice'. Never heard of them but the fee sounds fishy AF. Like they invented it on the spot. Why would *you* pay a fee to reconcile *their* books? Doesn't make sense. Usually, that's an internal thing for the broker. Are they even regulated? That's the first question you should ask. If they aren't regulated by a solid body like BaFin or FCA, consider your money gone. They probably have Terms & Conditions buried deep on their site that allow them to do this.

Leon Bauer · Berlin, Germanyanswered 26d ago
5

This is textbook. Total scam. They drain you dry with these made-up charges. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a new one for me, but it fits the usual pattern after the 'tax' or 'verification' demands. Never pay. Seriously. They prey on people's hope and desperation. I lost a sum to a group like this last year. They promised the moon, then hit me with a 'liquidity adjustment fee'. It's sickening. Stop all communication with them and report them everywhere you can. Filing a complaint with the CFTC might be a good step, though they primarily focus on US-regulated entities.

Andrew Anderson · Miami, USAanswered 26d ago
3

I am in the exact same boat. They told me I needed to pay a 'crypto transfer fee' to get my money out. Then it was a 'KYC validation fee'. This 'profit and loss reconciliation' fee they're asking you for sounds EXACTLY like their next move. My stomach is in knots. I'm in the Netherlands, and the AFM told me that if the broker is based offshore and not registered with them, their hands are tied too. I'm just trying to accept the loss and move on, but it's so hard. Don't pay another cent.

Anna de Groot · Nijmegen, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
4

Correct. This fee is fabricated. Brokers regulated by reputable authorities such as the FCA, ASIC, or BaFin would not demand such a payment from a client. Their internal accounting is their responsibility. The fact that FXChoice is requesting this suggests they are unregulated or operating illegally. The key thing to remember is that legitimate brokers allow withdrawals without these arbitrary 'fees' popping up at the last minute. Your initial intuition is correct; this is a scam tactic to extract more funds. You should report them to the relevant financial authorities in the jurisdiction they claim to operate from.

James Sullivan · Limerick, Irelandanswered 26d ago
2

Wait — are you sure about the name? FXChoice? I remember seeing ads for a similar-sounding broker but can't place it. Either way, this 'reconciliation fee' is BS. It's a made-up charge designed to scare you into paying more or just give up. They invented it. If they can't release your funds because of 'reconciling', that's their internal operational issue, not yours. I'd be very suspicious. Have you checked if they are listed on any official regulatory body's warning list, like the FCA's or ASIC's consumer warnings?

Amelia Pelletier · Victoria, Canadaanswered 26d ago
3

This is grim. I've seen this exact pattern with dodgy CFDs and crypto brokers operating out of places with lax oversight. They'll invent one fee after another – 'tax', 'admin', 'regulatory', and now this 'profit and loss reconciliation'. It's all smoke and mirrors. They know if you pay, you'll just get another fee demanded. Cut your losses and DO NOT pay it. Your best shot is to report them to ASIC if they claim any Australian connection, or whichever regulator they *claim* to be under. It's a long shot, but it's the only path other than losing it all.

Jack Jones · Canberra, Australiaanswered 26d ago
3

Ugh, I remember this. It was about two years ago for me. I'd made a decent bit on some forex pair, and then came the 'Admin Fee', then a 'Security Deposit', then this exact 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'. They sent me an invoice that looked like it came from a tax office! I ended up paying about €1500 extra in fees before realising I was being scammed. My wife told me to stop, but I was so deep in denial. Lost the lot. Just wanted to share my story. Don't send them more. Block them. Report to your local police too, just in case.

Paul Koch · Cologne, Germanyanswered 26d ago
2

Yeah, sounds like a scam to me too. What exactly are they reconciling? Did you have a specific P&L statement from them previously? If they can't just release the funds based on the agreed terms, it's shady. Why would they need a fee from you for their internal accounting? That's like asking a hairdresser to pay *you* to reconcile *their* appointment book. Lol, but seriously, just stop sending money. If they had real regulatory oversight, they wouldn't be asking for this.

Lucas Pelletier · Edmonton, Canadaanswered 26d ago
4

This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a classic scam tactic, sadly. It pops up when they realise you're onto them or trying to withdraw significant funds. They invent these fees to look legitimate, sometimes even sending fake invoices or 'regulatory' documents. It's all designed to get one last payment out of you. I lost R40,000 to a similar scam a few years ago; they requested a 'capital gains tax fee' before I could withdraw. It was devastating. Never pay these fabricated fees. Your best bet now is to report them to the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) here in South Africa if they have any pretence of being regulated here, or to the regulator in the country they *claim* to be based.

Lerato Dlamini · Pretoria, South Africaanswered 26d ago
2

This is horrible. They're exploiting you. The second they mentioned a 'tax clearance fee' and now this 'profit and loss reconciliation fee', it's a massive red flag. They are not a legitimate broker. My own experience with a shady platform involved a 'withdrawal processing fee', which then turned into a 'compliance fee'. There's always another fee. They try to make it sound official, but it's pure manipulation. Don't give them any more money. You might be able to report them to the Texas State Securities Board if they solicited you directly in Texas, but I'm not sure about offshore.

Brandon Garcia · San Antonio, USAanswered 26d ago
3

FXChoice? Never heard of them, but the fee structure sounds like pure scam. In Canada, we have FINTRAC, but that's more about money laundering. The provincial securities commissions are the ones that regulate brokers. If this FXChoice isn't registered with the Ontario Securities Commission or another provincial body, they're likely operating illegally. This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is bogus. They just want more money. They could be pretending to be regulated by someone like the FCA in the UK to seem legit. Don't pay. Report them to the Canadian Securities Administrators website.

Emma Bergeron · Winnipeg, Canadaanswered 26d ago
4

This is textbook scam behaviour. They invent fees as they go along. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee' is hilarious, frankly. They want to 'reconcile' their books with *your* money? Makes no sense. It's a tactic to make you pay more. Especially after you started questioning the 'tax clearance fee'. That was your cue to run. Don't pay it. They are unregulated, and they are thieves. Report them to the FCA *if* they falsely claim to be registered there. Even if they aren't, the FCA maintains a warning list.

Kevin Martin · Portland, USAanswered 26d ago
4

Oh my god, this sounds exactly like what happened to me with a platform called Elite FX Pro (might be defunct now). They hit me with a 'capital gains tax fee' after I tried to withdraw, then a 'regulatory compliance fee'. They even sent me a legit-looking PDF claiming it was from the 'Global Financial Standards Board' or something equally made up. It’s a known scam tactic. You need to report them immediately. Check the website of the regulator in the country they claim to be based in – if they claim to be regulated by the CFTC in the US, you can file a complaint there. They exist to track these operations.

Layla Al Nahyan · Ras Al Khaimah, UAEanswered 26d ago
3

This sounds incredibly familiar. They probably sent you a fabricated 'invoice' or 'agreement' that looks official, right? This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a common ploy. They want to make it seem like a legitimate administrative cost, but it's just a made-up charge to get more money from you. They are counting on the fact that you've already invested so much that you'll pay a little more to get it out. I've seen this with brokers who are not regulated by a body like the FCA or ASIC. Be extremely careful and DO NOT pay it. Report them to the financial regulator in the country they *claim* to be authorized in.

Jack Evans · Manchester, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
5

Mate, this is a known scam. 'FXChoice' is likely a shell, and these fees are completely made up. They are designed to hit you when you try to withdraw. I've heard similar stories about 'tax clearance' and 'reconciliation' fees from dodgy brokers. It’s a trap. The best practical tip here is: if a broker asks for *any* upfront fee to release *your* profits or capital, it's almost certainly a scam. Legitimate brokers deduct fees from the withdrawal amount itself, or have clear, pre-agreed charges. Report them to the FCA's consumer protection team in the UK, even if you're not based there, as they track these scams.

Oliver Walker · Adelaide, Australiaanswered 26d ago
3

Ugh, the fee games. I've been there. They hit me with a 'liquidity adjustment fee' then a 'brokerage settlement fee'. All nonsense. My wife kept telling me it sounded dodgy, but I was hoping too hard. They even sent me what looked like a government form! It's heartbreaking. I lost about $10k AUD. They operate out of somewhere with no real oversight. Check if FXChoice is on ASIC's scam warning list. If they're not regulated, there's not much the authorities can do to get your money back, but reporting them is still important. So sorry you're going through this.

Mees van Dijk · Almere, Netherlandsanswered 26d ago
3

I'm so sorry to hear this. It sounds exactly like a scam I encountered with a platform called 'Profit Leader FX' last year. They asked for a 'data verification fee' and then a 'withdrawal tax'. It's all fabricated to take your money. This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is just another excuse. They prey on people's hope. I'd advise you to stop communicating with them immediately and do not send them any more money. Look up the MAS Investor Alerts list for Singapore – see if FXChoice is on there. It's a long shot, but worth checking.

Mia Taylor · Darwin, Australiaanswered 26d ago
7

This sounds *exactly* like a 'advance fee' scam, common with unregulated Forex and CFD platforms. FXChoice itself has come up in scam reports before, sadly. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a made-up charge, designed to extract more money before they vanish. If they were legit, such fees wouldn't exist. MAS does regulate financial institutions, but their jurisdiction is primarily for companies operating *within* Singapore. For offshore brokers, reporting to your local police, perhaps, and financial crime units is usually the first step. Don't pay another cent.

Rachel Tay · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
5

Oh no, that sounds incredibly stressful. I can totally see why you're losing sleep over this. That 'fee' sounds so suspicious, especially after they pressured you to deposit more. It's such a common tactic for scam sites to invent new fees when you try to pull your money out. Just keep reminding yourself that this isn't your fault – these people are just really good at manipulating you. Sending you strength; hope you find a way through this.

Hao Ong · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
8

Listen, I've seen this movie before. They come up with these official-sounding fees – tax, reconciliation, regulatory clearance, whatever they think will scare you. FXChoice has been flagged. This is a classic exit scam. They will keep asking for more money. Block them. Report it to the Singapore Police Force Cybercrime unit, and also consider filing a complaint with an international body like the Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) even if you're not in the US, as it can help track them. This is a warning to others reading: if it sounds too good to be true and they pressure you to deposit, it IS a scam.

Omar Al Mansoori · Sharjah, UAEanswered 26d ago
10

Yep, that fee is pure BS. They invent them as you get closer to asking for your money back. I fell for something similar with OptionStarsGlobal a couple years ago. Started with crypto CFDs, then they wanted a 'data verification fee'. Paid it. Then a 'swaps adjustment fee'. Paid that too. Next thing I knew, my 'broker' vanished. Lost about $15k AUD. I never got a cent back. My advice? Cut your losses if you can, and chalk it up as an expensive lesson. And definitely report them to the FCA if they claim any UK ties at all, even if fake.

Andreas Neumann · Stuttgart, Germanyanswered 26d ago
7

This is an absolute classic of a Forex scam. They are *not* regulated if they are asking for these types of fees. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a complete fabrication. Regulators don't work like that, and legitimate brokers don't do that. They're trying to get you to pay more money. You need to stop communicating with them immediately. Do not send them any more money. Warn everyone you know about FXChoice. Seriously, if they have an address that looks like it's in Europe, you can try reporting them to BaFin or AFM, but don't expect much.

Grace Ryan · Galway, Irelandanswered 26d ago
9

Ugh, I feel for you. That sounds like the worst kind of stress. My story is a bit different, but the ending was the same – my 'broker' hit me with a 'compliance fee' to release funds once I'd made a decent profit. Took a big chunk of my savings too, though not quite as much as you. I eventually stopped paying, sent one last angry email, and just let it go. Reported it to the CFTC but honestly, felt like shouting into the void. These guys are predators. The one practical thing I learned: always check the regulator immediately. If it's not a major one like FCA or ASIC, walk away.

Brian Davis · Austin, USAanswered 26d ago
6

This is textbook. They lure you in with promises, pressure you to deposit more, and then invent fees to keep your money. FXChoice is likely unregulated or using a license from a blacklisted jurisdiction. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fiction. No legitimate broker would ever ask for this. They are trying to scam you. Do not send them any more money. Your MAS may not be able to help directly with an offshore entity, but reporting to them and the police here is still the right step. Maybe also the Hong Kong SFC if they have any HK registration.

Lauren Gonzalez · Phoenix, USAanswered 26d ago
5

Help... i'm in the same boat. They told me I needed to pay a 'capital gains tax' before I could withdraw my profits. It was like, THOUSANDS of dollars. I paid it on Tuesday, thinking it was real. Now they invented a new 'transfer fee'. I'm in tears, my husband is so angry. I told him it was a good investment. Now I owe money. I'm so scared. FXChoice said it was for 'compliance'. I wish I never signed up.

Lea Schroder · Dresden, Germanyanswered 26d ago
4

I keep reading these stories and honestly, it makes me sick. I was also with a fake broker, not FXChoice but someone similar, and they asked for a 'withdrawal permit fee' after I made a small profit. It wasn't a lot, maybe $500, but still. I argued with them for ages. They just kept saying it was 'mandatory for international transfers'. I feel so stupid now. I lost $500. You lost way more. I don't know what to suggest, but please know you're not alone. Reporting it to the police cybercrime unit here in Singapore was something I did, but felt like it went nowhere.

Jia Ng · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
5

This sounds incredibly dodgy. A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? From FXChoice, no less. Yeah, that's not a thing. They're trying to squeeze you for more cash. It's a common scam, especially with unregulated brokers targeting people interested in crypto or forex. They'll invent fees until you either pay up or they disappear. Since you're in Singapore, MAS is your best bet for lodging a complaint, even if they mainly regulate local firms. It creates a record. Also, look for any mention of them claiming to be regulated by the FCA or ASIC – if they are, report them there too. Good luck.

Liam Dlamini · Durban, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

I'm so sorry you're going through this. It's a truly awful situation. These 'fees' are pure manipulation. They see you want your money out and invent barriers. I never used FXChoice, but I had a similar experience with a platform called 'Global Trade Markets' (they're gone now, thank goodness). After I deposited a decent sum, they suddenly required a 'risk assessment fee' before allowing any withdrawal. It was hundreds of dollars. I bit the bullet and paid it, hoping to get *something* back. Alas, they blocked my account after. Don't pay it. It's a trap.

Mia Tremblay · Victoria, Canadaanswered 26d ago
5

Aw man, this is rough. Same sort of thing happened to me with another broker, not FXChoice however. I was told I needed to pay a 'VAT fee' on my profits before withdrawal – which is rubbish, as I'm not in the UK. They sent me some official-looking docs too. I paid it. Then they slapped me with a 'currency conversion fee'. By that point, I saw the pattern. They are just bleeding you dry. I stopped paying. Lost about £8k. The sad truth is, if they're unregulated, getting your money back might be impossible. Reporting to the FCA, even if they only *claim* to be regulated there, might put them on the radar.

Isla Wilson · Edinburgh, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
6

This is not a new tactic; it's an old one dressed up in new jargon. 'Profit and Loss Reconciliation Fee' sounds professional but it's nonsense. If FXChoice is indeed unregulated or operates from a jurisdiction with weak oversight, they are essentially a high-risk platform. The fact they pressured you to deposit more is a huge red flag. Report them to MAS, yes, but also file a complaint with your local police's cybercrime unit. They often liaise with international agencies. Also, check if they have any affiliation with any entity regulated by the major bodies like the FCA in the UK, and report them there too.

William Gagne · Ottawa, Canadaanswered 26d ago
5

Oh dear, this is heartbreaking to read. I wish I had better news, but that 'fee' sounds like a very common scam. I lost a substantial amount ($10k CAD equivalent) to a similar scam about 18 months ago. They also invented fees – first a 'tax fee', then a 'transaction fee'. It's designed to keep you paying until they either get all your money or they just disappear. Sadly, if FXChoice isn't regulated by a reputable authority like the FCA or ASIC, your chances of recovering funds are slim to none. Keep all records religiously.

Grace Dlamini · Bloemfontein, South Africaanswered 26d ago
4

That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is definitely a scam tactic. FXChoice has been mentioned on scam forums before, unfortunately. They prey on people's hope for quick gains. They will invent more and more fees. Don't pay anything else. Your best bet is to report it toMAS and the Singapore Police Force. If you can find any mention of them being registered or claiming to be regulated by the FCA or ASIC, report it to them as well. It might not get your money back, but it helps build a case against them.

Lea Becker · Dusseldorf, Germanyanswered 26d ago
3

I'm so, so sorry you're going through this. It's a horrible feeling. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is just another excuse to get more money from you. It's infuriating how they invent these things. I had a similar situation with a broker in Cyprus that claimed to be regulated, but wasn't. They kept asking for 'fees' for months. I eventually gave up. Cut your losses now. Don't send FXChoice another cent. Gather all your evidence – emails, invoices, chat logs – and report them to MAS and your local police. That's all you can really do.

Edward Walker · Birmingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

This sounds exactly like the kind of scam I encountered a while back with a platform not unlike FXChoice. They hit me with a 'security deposit fee' after I'd supposedly made good profits. Total rubbish. They just want to keep you hooked and paying. My suggestion is to stop all communication and immediately report them. Since you're in Singapore, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) is the correct body to report to. Also, file a report with the Singapore Police Force. It's a long shot, but it's the right thing to do.

Emily Jones · Bristol, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
5

This is textbook. That 'fee' isn't real. They are trying to scam you. FXChoice is known to be dodgy. Don't pay. Just block them and report it. MAS in Singapore is your first stop. You could also report it to the FCA as they have powers over firms marketing to UK residents, even if the firm is overseas. Keep all your emails and screenshots. My uncle fell for this, lost his life savings. He never got a penny back. It ruins people.

Logan Bouchard · Edmonton, Canadaanswered 26d ago
4

Yeah, that ‘profit and loss reconciliation fee’ is pure fiction. I fell for something similar with a crypto exchange that had decent ad placement. They told me I owed a ‘blockchain audit fee’ to release my funds. It was about $2k. I paid it. Then they asked for another ‘compliance fee’. That’s when I realized it was a scam. I never got my money back. Lost $12k in total. Cut your losses with FXChoice and do not send them any more money. Reporting it to the police here in Canada is what I did, and it felt like doing *something*, even if it didn't recover funds.

Louis Petit · Nantes, Franceanswered 26d ago
4

Oh mate, that sounds brutal. That 'fee' is a fabrication, pure and simple. They invent these things when they're ready to take you for all you're worth. FXChoice has a bad reputation, sadly. Don't send them another penny. Your best bet is reporting it to MAS, and also to the police cybercrime unit. Gather every bit of evidence you have – emails, transaction records, chat logs. It's a long shot, but these reports can help build a case against these operations. It's a hard lesson, but don't let it beat you.

Sophia Fortin · Edmonton, Canadaanswered 26d ago
7

This sounds textbook scam territory. FXChoice isn't a regulated entity I recognize, and these 'fees' – profit and loss reconciliation, tax clearance, etc. – are classic red flags. They invent these arbitrary costs to bleed you dry. If they can't provide a valid regulatory license and clear terms of service upfront, it's already a bad sign. Honestly, you're unlikely to ever see that money again. The invoice itself is likely faked. Don't pay them another cent. The only responsible step now is reporting.

Adam Garcia · Toulouse, Franceanswered 26d ago
5

Oh god, i know this feeling. like my stomach just dropped when i read your post. that P&L fee... sounds so legit on paper but it's pure BS. i went through something similar with another outfit, OptionStarsGlobal they called themselves. they wanted a 'compliance fee' after i 'made' a killing. told me the same thing about regulators needing it balanced. i paid it. then they hit me with another one. lost like a thousand dollars before i realised. FXChoice is probably the same. i reported them to Singapore police, but they said it's outside their jurisdiction for offshore. doesn't hurt to file an MAS report anyway if they have any local presence, or a cybercrime one.

Xin Goh · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 26d ago
5

STOP. Whatever you do, do NOT pay this 'reconciliation fee'. It's a pure fabrication designed to extract more cash. These scam brokers operate by inventing fees as you try to withdraw. They'll just invent another excuse and another fee if you pay this one. FXChoice is known for this kind of predatory behaviour. They prey on people's hope and lack of knowledge about financial regulations. You've described the common playbook. The best path forward is to cut your losses if you can, and report them. Never trust an unregulated broker pushing high returns.

Charlotte Williams · Nottingham, United Kingdomanswered 26d ago
4

This is a distressingly common scam tactic, sadly. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fictitious charge. Legitimate financial institutions do not operate this way. Regulators require transparency and adherence to rules, but they don't mandate brokers to charge clients arbitrary fees to 'balance books' like this. FXChoice is likely an unregulated or offshore entity that operates outside of reputable financial oversight. The invoice is probably a forgery. Your best course of action is to cease all communication with them and file reports with relevant authorities. In the US, the CFTC and your state's securities regulator are good starting points.

Sarah Lopez · Phoenix, USAanswered 26d ago
4

I can relate. I'm in the same boat, almost exactly. Except mine was with a different fake broker. They also kept pushing me to invest more and more, and when I finally tried to take out just a little bit, they hit me with some BS 'administrative fee'. Then it was a 'withdrawal tax'. They even sent me a fake government letter. i was so blind! I ended up paying them about $5k extra before I realised. Now they're totally ghosting me. I'm reporting to the FBI IC3, but i don't have much hope.

Samantha Wilson · Denver, USAanswered 26d ago
4

That's a rough situation, really sorry you're going through this. It sounds exactly like a scam. These fabricated fees are designed to confuse and extort. FXChoice, if they're not licensed by a major regulator like the FCA or ASIC, is likely operating illegally. Don't pay them any more money. My advice? Try and see if you can report them through our equivalent of the MAS here in Ireland, maybe the Central Bank of Ireland website or the Financial Regulator. They might not be able to recover your funds, but they can investigate and possibly shut them down.

Sean Byrne · Galway, Irelandanswered 26d ago
4

Ugh, the fee merry-go-round. Been there. My 'broker' was also offshore, promised the moon. When I asked for my initial deposit back, suddenly there was a 'server maintenance fee'. Then a 'capital gains tax verification fee'. They even sent me a link to some fake 'tax authority' website. It was all lies. I lost about $8k total. My wife told me to stop, but I kept thinking 'just one more deposit, then I can get it all out'. Never believe that. FXChoice is pulling the same trick. If you're in the US, go to FTC.gov and report it there.

Matthew Hall · Austin, USAanswered 26d ago
3

This is a very common scam, unfortunately. The 'Profit and Loss Reconciliation Fee' is a phantom charge. Regulated brokers do not levy such fees on clients to 'balance books'. Authorities like the FCA (UK), BaFin (Germany), or ASIC (Australia) have strict rules, and this doesn't align with any of them. FXChoice is likely operating without proper oversight. The 'invoice' is a fabrication. Your best bet is to report this to the UAE's Securities and Commodities Authority (SCA) or the relevant financial services regulator in your specific Emirate immediately. While recovery is difficult, reporting is crucial.

Noor Ahmed · Al Ain, UAEanswered 26d ago
3

Mate, this is a classic scam. That fee is 100% made up. FXChoice sounds like a clone or a scam outfit. They invent these fees to keep your money. They've probably never been regulated by anyone important like the FCA. You might as well be trying to get money back from a Nigerian prince. Don't pay it. Report them to Action Fraud in the UK. They can't get your money back usually, but they log the complaints and build cases. It's the best you can do now.

Harry Smith · Sheffield, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
3

I had something similar happen last year with another dodgy FX platform. They wanted a 'currency conversion fee' after I 'made' a load of fake profit. It went on and on. I got so fed up I just stopped communicating. Lost a few hundred euros, thankfully not as much as you. My bank (Commerzbank) said since it was an international transfer to an unregulated entity, they couldn't do much. It's frustrating because they make it sound so official. But yeah, these fees are just more hurdles to keep your cash. Don't pay.

David Wagner · Stuttgart, Germanyanswered 25d ago
3

OMG, this is exactly what happened to me two months ago! Mine was called 'GoldenBridge Capital' or something equally stupid. They also wanted a 'tax validation fee' and then a 'profit release fee'. It was so stressful, I was crying every night. My husband said to just forget it, but it was my savings too. I paid them an extra £3k altogether. They just kept asking for more. Now my account is just closed and they won't answer. There's no point paying them. We're looking into reporting them but honestly, who knows?

Charlie Davies · London, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
3

I'm so sorry. This is a nightmare scenario. They invent fees like this 'P&L reconciliation fee' to keep you hooked and paying. It's a common scam by unregulated brokers. They look professional, they send invoices, but it's all a lie. FXChoice has popped up on scam warning sites before, so that's not good. The MAS *might* be able to offer some guidance even if the broker is offshore, or you could report it to the police's cybercrime unit. It’s worth a shot.

Hannah Green · Edinburgh, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
3

This sounds horrifically familiar. I lost a decent sum to a similar scam, though not FXChoice specifically. They invented an 'anti-money laundering check fee' right before I could withdraw. It was a significant amount, almost 10% of my supposed 'winnings'. They sent documents that looked official. I ended up paying it because I was so desperate to get my money out and thought it was a final hurdle. Turns out, it was just another way to steal from me. They never let me withdraw anything after that. Don't pay any more fees.

Lotte van Dijk · Almere, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
3

Ah, the classic 'fee-to-withdraw' scam. Happens all the time with these dodgy outfits. FXChoice is likely not regulated by the FCA, AFM, or ASIC. They create these fake fees as a final barrier. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is nonsense. They want to keep your money! You should report them to the AFM if they have any presence in the Netherlands, or to any financial regulator where they claim to be based. Don't pay them a single euro more. Block them if you can.

Charlie Johnson · Gold Coast, Australiaanswered 25d ago
3

This is exactly the same scam I almost fell for with OptionStarsGlobal. They hit me with a 'withdrawal processing fee' after I 'made' thousands. Same story about regulators and balancing books. Thankfully, my dad saw the 'invoice' they sent and told me to google it. Found loads of people saying it was a scam. I refused to pay and they basically froze my account and stopped responding. It's terrifying how real it looks. Don't pay them! Report them to ASIC if they claim any Australian connection.

Liam van der Merwe · Pretoria, South Africaanswered 25d ago
3

This is a textbook example of a 'phishing scam' combined with advance-fee fraud. The 'Profit and Loss Reconciliation Fee' is entirely fabricated. Reputable brokers licensed by authorities like the CFTC or BaFin do not charge clients such fees to release funds; regulatory compliance is handled internally and through established procedures, not ad-hoc client charges. FXChoice is likely operating illegally. Your immediate step should be to report this activity to the relevant cybersecurity and financial fraud reporting agencies in your jurisdiction.

David Allen · Chicago, USAanswered 25d ago
3

Oh man, that sounds awful. Similar thing happened to me, but thankfully it was a smaller amount. They wanted an 'international transfer fee' and then a 'risk assessment fee'. It took me a while to realize it was a scam because they were so slick. My bank, Chase, couldn't do anything really because it was offshore. A guy I talked to told me to report it to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) website. They collect complaints like this. Don't send them any more money, please.

Levi van Dijk · Utrecht, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
3

This is a very common tactic used by unregulated 'brokers'. They invent all sorts of absurd fees – 'compliance fees', 'tax clearance', 'reconciliation fees' – to extort money from clients just before they can withdraw. FXChoice is very likely a scam operation. They prey on people's desire for quick profits. Reporting is your only real option now. File a complaint with the Autoriteit Financiële Markten (AFM) in the Netherlands, or their local equivalent wherever they claim to be registered. It's unlikely you'll get your money back directly, but it helps authorities track them.

Edward Hughes · Liverpool, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
3

No, this is not a new tactic, it's an old, nasty one. FXChoice is likely a scam platform. They'll keep inventing fees. 'P&L Reconciliation', 'tax', this, that. It's all to get more money from you. I lost £5k on a similar thing through a broker called 'Apex Markets'. They sent fake letters from HMRC. My own bank blocked any further transfers to them. Check if your bank has any fraud reporting line you can use, and definitely report to Action Fraud.

Isla Harris · Hobart, Australiaanswered 25d ago
3

This sounds exactly like the scam I encountered! They demanded a 'capital gains tax payment' before releasing 'profits'. They said it was for the 'foreign exchange regulatory body'. It looked so official, with logos and everything. I paid it, and then they asked for a 'transfer fee'. I eventually lost about $10k. In the UAE, I reported it to the UAE Central Bank. They were helpful in explaining that such fees are never legitimate. You should report FXChoice to the SCA here immediately. They probably won't retrieve your funds but they can take action.

Faisal Sheikh · Ras Al Khaimah, UAEanswered 25d ago
12

This is textbook. FXChoice is a known entity involved in these types of scams. The 'fees' - tax, reconciliation, etc. - are all fabricated to extract more money. They prey on fear and ignorance. Since you're in Singapore, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) is your primary local regulator. You should formally complain to them, providing all documented communication and transaction details, even if they claim FXChoice is offshore. They have mechanisms for reporting unregulated entities operating within their jurisdiction. Also, check if they have any licensing claims that are false – e.g., claiming to be FCA regulated when they are not.

Joshua Lau · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 25d ago
8

Oh no, that sounds absolutely terrible. I can only imagine how stressed you must be. Please try not to blame yourself too much; these scammers are really good at what they do, and it's easy to fall for it when they promise big returns. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds like total nonsense. I haven't heard of that specific one, but it fits the pattern of other scams I've seen where they just invent fees. Hang in there, and hopefully, someone here has some solid advice for you.

Felix Schmidt · Leipzig, Germanyanswered 25d ago
8

Wait a minute, a 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? That doesn't sound like a real thing in legitimate trading. If a broker has regulatory obligations, those costs are generally built into their overall operational expenses, not passed on as a special per-client fee like this. They're likely just making it up as they go along. I'd be very surprised if FXChoice is anything more than a shell designed to do exactly this. Have you looked into their regulatory status yourself? i.e. are they actually registered with anyone reputable like the FCA or BaFin?

Levi de Groot · Utrecht, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
10

I'm so sorry you're going through this. I had a similar experience, though not with FXChoice specifically. I was dealing with OptionStarsGlobal, and they tried to hit me with a 'verification fee' after I requested a withdrawal. Then it was a 'transaction processing charge.' It's the same pattern, isn't it? They just keep inventing new demands. I remember feeling so sick to my stomach, just like you described. I haven't recovered the money yet, but I did report them to the CFTC, even though they were supposedly offshore. It's worth a shot.

Ciara Walsh · Galway, Irelandanswered 25d ago
10

This is unfortunately a very common scam vector for offshore CFD and crypto brokers. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a made-up charge. Regulators don't require brokers to charge clients specific fees like this to reconcile P&L; that's an internal accounting matter. FXChoice is likely not regulated by any reputable authority, or if they claim to be, it's a lie or a very weak offshore license. For Singapore, MAS is indeed the correct body to report to. You should also gather all evidence for potential action through consumer protection agencies if MAS cannot directly assist with recovery. Consider filing a report with the IC3 (Internet Crime Complaint Center) in the US as well; they track these types of cross-border scams.

Lucas Walker · Gold Coast, Australiaanswered 25d ago
6

Oh dear, that sounds like a horrible situation to be in. It's completely understandable that you're stressed; worrying about your savings is a huge burden. This fee sounds very suspicious indeed. Try to take deep breaths. It's good you're questioning it instead of just paying. We're all rooting for you here and hope someone can offer some practical steps to get your money back. Don't give up hope just yet!

Sophie Sullivan · Dublin, Irelandanswered 25d ago
9

I'm in a similar boat, friend. Not FXChoice, but another broker. They told me I needed to pay an 'anti-money laundering compliance fee' before they'd release a small withdrawal I requested weeks ago. It was like, SGD 2000. I paid it because I was so desperate, and now they've vanished. Their website is gone. I feel like such an idiot. My wife is furious. I don't know what to do now. I'm in Singapore too and emailed MAS but haven't heard back yet.

David Koch · Frankfurt, Germanyanswered 25d ago
7

A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds like pure garbage. Seriously. What does that even mean? It's not a standard practice in the industry, at least not one that legitimate brokers would ever ask a client to pay directly like this. They're digging for more cash. Your gut feeling is probably spot on. Check the domain registration date for FXChoice's website too; often these scam sites are relatively new. If they're not regulated by a serious body like the FCA, CFTC, or ASIC, then that's a massive red flag.

Kevin Davis · Phoenix, USAanswered 25d ago
7

Ah, that sounds like a very frustrating situation. It seems like these brokers have an endless supply of invented fees. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is definitely not standard practice. Legitimate brokers handle their internal reconciliation as part of their operational costs. It's good that you're asking questions and not just paying blindly. MAS is the right place to report them, even for offshore entities targeting Singaporean residents. Keep all records meticulously.

Omar Al Mansoori · Ras Al Khaimah, UAEanswered 25d ago
8

This whole thing stinks to high heaven. A 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is totally made up. They are just stringing you along. Honestly, these FXChoice people are notorious. I've seen reports about them using similar tactics. Don't pay anything else. Once they have your money, they just invent new excuses. Did you check their regulatory status anywhere? Like, are they actually licensed by the FCA in the UK, or BaFin in Germany? If they're just operating without a license, or with a fake one, then it's game over for them.

Hannah Lee · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 25d ago
12

This sounds exactly like the 'Advance Fee Fraud' scam. They lure you in with promises of high returns (investment scam), then once you want your money back, they invent fictional fees or taxes that you must pay before withdrawal. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is just the latest guise. They'll keep asking for more if you pay this one. Your best bet is to report them immediately to the relevant authorities. For offshore brokers targeting Singaporeans, MAS is the primary point of contact. Also, consider reporting to international bodies like the IC3 (Internet Crime Complaint Center) and the financial regulator in the jurisdiction where FXChoice claims to be based (if they even claim one). Don't fall for any further requests for payment.

Lea Garcia · Montpellier, Franceanswered 25d ago
10

Oh man, I was in a similar spot last year. I lost about 8k USD to one of these shady CFD brokers. They kept telling me I needed to pay 'capital gains tax' and then 'withdrawal processing fees.' In the end, I just kissed the money goodbye. I couldn't afford to pay them any more and I felt too ashamed to tell my parents. What I did, though, after I gave up on getting my money back, was report them everywhere I could think of – MAS, some Australian regulator (ASIC, I think?), and even just filed a police report locally. It felt good to at least make them aware, even if it didn't get my money back.

Wei Tan · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 25d ago
10

This is classic. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is pure fabrication. Legitimate brokers do not charge clients for internal accounting processes. FXChoice is almost certainly a scam operation. They operate on the principle of 'never let the investor get their money out'. Because you're in Singapore, the MAS is the correct regulatory body to file a complaint with. Make sure to include all correspondence, statements, and invoices. Also, check if FXChoice claims to be regulated anywhere. If they claim a jurisdiction like the UK (FCA) or Germany (BaFin), fake that claim with the respective regulator's website to confirm if they are authorized.

Emma Tremblay · Ottawa, Canadaanswered 25d ago
11

Ugh, this sounds so familiar. I got caught by a similar scam a couple of years ago with a crypto platform. They kept asking for more and more money for 'verification fees' and 'security deposits.' It's always some BS reason. I ended up losing about CAD 10,000. It was devastating. I never got any of it back. What I learned the hard way, though? Always, always check financial regulator websites BEFORE depositing. If they aren't on the FCA, ASIC, BaFin, or CFTC lists, walk away. Seriously. That's the best preventative measure. It's too late now for us, but maybe others can learn.

Lily Mokoena · East London, South Africaanswered 25d ago
9

That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds like total nonsense. It's not a standard fee in forex or CFD trading. Brokers usually factor operational costs into their spreads or commissions. They are likely just inventing this to get more money from you. My advice? Stop communicating with them directly about payments. Instead, focus on reporting them. Since you're in Singapore, definitely file a complaint with the MAS. Also, check the website of the regulator in the country where FXChoice claims to be based. If they claim to be regulated by the FCA (UK) or BaFin (Germany), check those regulators' official lists to see if they are actually licensed.

Layla Al Marri · Ras Al Khaimah, UAEanswered 25d ago
10

I fell for a similar scam where a broker needed a 'tax payment' before releasing funds. Lost about £5,000. They sent me fake HMRC documents and everything. It felt so real at the time. They kept saying 'final payment' but then there was always another fee. Eventually, they just disappeared. I reported it to the FCA, but they said since the company was overseas, they couldn't do much directly. It’s a good lesson, albeit a painful one. Always be skeptical of fees requested *after* you've invested and want to withdraw.

Jason Anderson · Portland, USAanswered 25d ago
11

This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a classic scam tactic. They invent fees as a gatekeeper to prevent you from withdrawing your funds. It's a psychological trick; they make you think it's a procedural step rather than outright theft. Since FXChoice is likely unregulated or using shady offshore licenses, your path here is reporting. For you in Singapore, lodge a formal complaint with the MAS. Provide them with all evidence: emails, chat logs, invoices, transaction records. Also, consider reporting to the FBI's IC3 (Internet Crime Complaint Center) as these are often international operations.

Saar van den Berg · Breda, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
6

That fee sounds completely made up. I've worked in finance for years and never heard of such a thing being charged directly to a retail client. It's definitely a red flag. Don't pay it! The best approach is to file a formal complaint with the MAS in Singapore. They regulate financial services and can investigate entities targeting Singaporean residents. Keep all your records organized – emails, transaction history, any communication. It’s crucial evidence.

Lina Moreau · Toulouse, Franceanswered 25d ago
6

Oh gosh, that sounds incredibly stressful. Similar situation happened to my cousin. He invested with a platform that promised huge crypto returns, and when he wanted to withdraw, they demanded a 'compliance fee' and then a 'transfer fee.' He ended up paying quite a bit extra before realizing it was a scam. Please don't send them any more money. Report them to MAS. It sounds like the standard procedure for these offshore scams.

Andrew Gonzalez · San Antonio, USAanswered 25d ago
9

This is sadly a very common scam. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is just another made-up charge designed to extract more money from victims. They often use official-looking invoices to make it seem legitimate. Do not pay it. Since you are in Singapore, your best course of action is to report FXChoice to the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS). Provide them with all the evidence you have. It's also worth checking if FXChoice claims to be regulated by any authority and then verifying that claim on the regulator's official website (e.g., FCA, BaFin).

Thomas Williams · Birmingham, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
5

My friend, this sounds like the classic 'advance fee' scam, repackaged. They invent fees – tax, reconciliation, administrative, whatever – to keep you paying while they string you along. FXChoice is known for this, sadly. Honestly, any broker that sounds too good to be true usually is. They prey on people wanting a quick win. Never pay these 'fees'. It's a dead end.

Rachel Harris · Nottingham, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
7

Oh gosh, I feel for you SO much. This sounds exactly like what happened to me a couple years back with OptionStarsGlobal. They hit me with a 'compliance fee' then a 'withdrawal processing fee'. Said it was for regulatory reasons. It was all lies to get every last cent. Cut your losses if you can, even if it hurts. I ended up losing most of my savings.

Lina Thomas · Bordeaux, Franceanswered 25d ago
6

Red flag! Big time. This is a common tactic for shady brokers. They create fake 'fees' to keep you in their game. They'll invent more and more reasons to demand money. Trust your gut; it's screaming the truth. Don't send them another cent. Report them to wherever you can, even if they're offshore. Every little bit helps scare them off.

Naledi Mokoena · East London, South Africaanswered 25d ago
5

I went through something similar with a crypto platform last year. They promised the moon and then started asking for 'verification fees' and later 'capital gains tax' before I could withdraw my own money. I was in Dubai, so I asked around. The advice I got was to never send more money and to file a complaint with the financial crimes unit here, even if the company is overseas. It probably won't get my money back, but it might stop them from doing it to someone else.

Sara Iqbal · Ras Al Khaimah, UAEanswered 25d ago
4

This is heartbreaking. I've seen this exact same thing happen to friends. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is just theater. They don't have regulators demanding this; they're inventing it. They want you to feel like it's official so you'll pay. The key is to NEVER pay any unexpected fees to withdraw. It's a trap. You've done well to question it.

Hannah Roberts · Bristol, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
6

I'm in Singapore too and dealt with a similar broker back in 2022. They kept asking for more money for 'regulatory adjustments'. I escalated it to MAS, and while they can't force offshore brokers to act, they logged my complaint. It made me feel a bit better. Also, check if the broker has any registration with financial authorities in their *own* country. If they don't, that's a huge red flag. I'm so sorry you're going through this.

Ming Ong · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 25d ago
4

Hmm, 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? Sounds made up. Brokers usually handle their own internal reconciliation. Asking the client for a fee to do it seems... odd. Especially if they're claiming it's for regulators. Most regulated firms have to handle that stuff themselves. Maybe look for any official registration details for FXChoice on the FCA or CFTC website? If they're not registered there, that's a problem.

Ethan Smith · Montreal, Canadaanswered 25d ago
5

Ah, the advance fee scam! They get you in with promises, then keep you hooked with ever-increasing 'requirements' to withdraw. That 'fee' is pure fabrication. It's designed to look official with that 'invoice'. A real, regulated broker wouldn't do this. They'd deduct taxes or fees, sure, but not ask for a separate payment like this. Don't pay it. Seriously.

David Koch · Leipzig, Germanyanswered 25d ago
4

This is awful. I'm so sorry you're in this position. Take a deep breath. Your gut feeling is right. These 'fees' are almost always a scam. The best thing you can do now is stop interacting with them regarding payments. Instead, start gathering all your documentation and see if you can file a report with the MAS, even if the broker is offshore. Document everything - emails, chat logs, invoices. Every bit of evidence helps.

Lucas Bernard · Lyon, Franceanswered 25d ago
4

Believe me, I know that feeling. I got suckered by a similar setup. They said I needed to pay a 'financial security bond' before they'd release the 'profits' they showed me. It was a lie. They just wanted more cash. I lost a lot, like, around $15k. I tried reporting it, but because it was an offshore entity, it felt like shouting into the void. Just be careful, man. Don't send them more money.

Mason Gagnon · Montreal, Canadaanswered 25d ago
5

This is a textbook advance-fee fraud. FXChoice and similar entities operate in a regulatory grey area, preying on individuals attracted by high-yield promises. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fabrication. Registered brokers don't solicit such payments from clients post-trade for internal accounting. What you NEED to do is check if FXChoice has any kind of license or registration with a reputable financial authority like the FCA in the UK or ASIC in Australia. If they don't, you're dealing with an unregulated entity, and these fees are a scam mechanism. Do not pay.

Sophie Jones · London, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
5

This sounds exactly like the sort of thing that OptionStarsGlobal used to pull. They'd invent these ridiculous fees – 'server maintenance', 'account activation', you name it. They just kept asking for more. It is a scam, plain and simple. They want to bleed you dry. You MUST NOT pay them any more money. Seriously, cut your losses before it gets worse. Report them to ASIC if they have any Australian connection, but tbh, it's hard to get money back from these guys.

Mia Jones · Gold Coast, Australiaanswered 25d ago
4

I fell for this too. A broker said I needed to pay something called a 'liquidity provision fee' to get my money out. I thought it was legit because they sent an official-looking document. It was a total scam. They just took the extra money and then ghosted me. I lost about €8,000. They were based somewhere in Eastern Europe. I reported it to the AFM, but they said they couldn't do much since the company wasn't regulated by them. Learned my lesson the hard way.

Liam Meijer · Nijmegen, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
4

They tried this with me too. Said I owed a 'compliance verification fee' to release 'profits'. I was in Toronto, obviously nowhere near FXChoice's supposed base. I asked them to deduct it from the withdrawal amount, and they suddenly went quiet. Then they came up with more excuses. Eventually, I just gave up trying to get the money out. It's devastating. Don't pay anything more to them.

Ahmed Al Qasimi · Dubai, UAEanswered 25d ago
5

This is precisely the sort of fraudulent activity these offshore, unregulated brokers engage in. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is entirely fabricated. Legitimate financial institutions do not extort clients with such invented charges for internal processes. They rely on the veneer of legitimacy provided by official-looking documents like invoices and the threat of regulatory complicity. It's crucial to understand that you NEVER have to pay a fee to receive funds you are rightfully owed. Consider reporting this to the UAE Securities and Commodities Authority, even if the broker is not based here. Documentation is key.

Thomas Jones · Newcastle, Australiaanswered 25d ago
6

I'm an accountant, and that 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds like absolute rubbish. Brokers don't charge clients for that. It's part of their own operational costs. If they were regulated by someone like ASIC, there might be official fees, but they wouldn't be charged to you like this, and the regulator would be named. This is a classic pump-and-dump fee structure. My advice? Check the ASIC register for FXChoice. If they're not there, you've been scammed.

Jia Tan · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 25d ago
4

I truly feel for you. This is a difficult situation. Your instincts are spot on, this fee is a scam. They invented it. What you can do is report this incident to MAS. Even though the broker is offshore, MAS keeps a register of complaints, and it might help them warn other consumers. It's definitely worth trying. Keep all communication records.

Alice Leroy · Nice, Franceanswered 25d ago
4

Yeah, I've seen similar things. They string you along with fake profits, then hit you with 'fees' when you try to cash out. That 'reconciliation' fee is just nonsense. Never heard of such a thing. They'll keep inventing fees until you give up or run out of money. I wouldn't send them a cent more. Maybe check if they're mentioned on any scam warning lists?

Logan Bergeron · Edmonton, Canadaanswered 25d ago
5

This entire scenario screams fraud. A fee for 'profit and loss reconciliation' is not a standard financial practice demanded from retail clients. Regulated entities, such as those overseen by BaFin or the FCA, have strict protocols. They might charge *you* for trading costs, but they wouldn't invent a fee post-profit to 'balance the books' for regulators. This is a deception tactic. Your best recourse is to immediately stop all communication regarding payments and file a formal complaint with the appropriate financial authority in your jurisdiction, even if the broker is offshore. The CFTC in the US has a complaint portal, for example.

Ava Anderson · Darwin, Australiaanswered 25d ago
6

This is a horrible situation, but unfortunately, quite common with unregulated brokers. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a complete fabrication designed to extract more money from you. They essentially create a fake problem that only your money can solve. If you try to pay it, they'll likely invent another fee. The fact that FXChoice is asking for this is a massive red flag. Search for FXChoice on the FCA or ASIC registers. If they aren't listed, they aren't regulated, and this is a scam.

Michael Schmidt · Dresden, Germanyanswered 25d ago
7

This sounds like classic advance-fee fraud, unfortunately. FXChoice is known for this kind of thing. They're not regulated by any major authority that would protect you. The fees — tax, reconciliation, whatever they come up with next… it's all smoke and mirrors designed to keep you sending money. As for MAS, they can investigate if the broker is locally licensed, but for offshore entities, your recourse is limited. Did you ever check their regulatory status on the FCA's or ASIC's websites before depositing? That's usually the first red flag.

Wei Chan · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 25d ago
3

OMG, the same thing happened to me! Different broker name, but the P&L reconciliation fee scam? Spot on. They kept saying 'regulatory compliance' and 'account squaring.' It just got worse and worse. I lost about $20k USD. I reported it to the police here in Sharjah, but they said it's hard because the company is overseas. The only thing that stopped me from sending more was my wife seeing the 'invoice' and saying it looked fake. Keep your money. Don't send them another cent. It's gone.

Hassan Al Maktoum · Sharjah, UAEanswered 25d ago
5

Yes, this is a scam. No legitimate broker, especially one dealing cross-border like FXChoice appears to be, will demand arbitrary 'reconciliation' fees to release your funds. They might have tax reporting requirements, but that's different. This sounds like they are trying to bleed you dry. My advice is to cut your losses now, even if it means not getting your initial investment back. Reporting them to BaFin might not help directly since they're not German, but it adds to a database of complaints. Stop all communication and move on.

Paul Klein · Hamburg, Germanyanswered 25d ago
4

Oh dear, this is a very common scam tactic. Unregulated brokers are notorious for inventing fees to avoid paying out. 'Profit and Loss Reconciliation Fee' sounds completely made up. If it were a real thing, it would be part of the trading contract or platform terms you agreed to, not an extra demand later. ASIC is strict, but they primarily regulate Australian financial services. Keep all the communication records you have. You can try reporting it via the Australian Cyber Security Centre, even if FXChoice is overseas, to at least flag them.

Ava Jones · Hobart, Australiaanswered 25d ago
6

This is absolutely a scam. I've seen this play out countless times. They lure you in with promises, get you to invest, and then invent fees to trap your money. The 'invoice' is probably just a doctored PDF. No regulated broker, not under AFM, would operate like this. Trying to get money back from these offshore operations is nearly impossible. The best you can do now is to not send them any more money and be extremely wary of anyone promising high returns online. Seriously, check regulators like the FCA or CFTC directly for broker lists.

Lucas de Jong · Rotterdam, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
2

Hmm, 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' sounds fishy. Why would they need to reconcile your P&L to release *your* funds? That's usually an internal accounting thing for them. They probably just see you trying to withdraw and are inventing new hurdles. I'd be very suspicious. Did you check if they're even regulated by a reputable body? Like, seriously, did you go to the FCA's site and look them up? Probably not, or you wouldn't be asking. Block them and move on.

Noor Al Falasi · Al Ain, UAEanswered 25d ago
3

I feel your pain. I was in a similar situation a couple of years back with a crypto platform, not FX, but the fees were insane. They hit me with a 'withdrawal processing fee,' then a 'compliance verification fee.' It never ended. Lost about a third of what I put in. Luckily, I managed to pull out the rest before they invented another demand. What stopped me from sending more cash was a friend who's a compliance officer saying these fees are almost always fraudulent. Don't pay. Cut contact. Just block them.

Lucas Brown · Canberra, Australiaanswered 25d ago
4

Wait — 'profit and loss reconciliation fee'? That sounds like something they just made up on the spot. A broker's job is to facilitate trades and hold funds, not to charge you fees to 'reconcile' your supposed profits. That's their problem, not yours. If they're not regulated by, say, the AMF in France or another EU authority, then they're essentially offshore cowboys. You likely won't see that money again, sadly. The best tip? Always, always check the regulator's website before depositing any cash.

Lucas Petit · Montpellier, Franceanswered 25d ago
7

This is a textbook advance-fee scam. FXChoice itself has a history flagged on consumer protection sites. The 'fees' are fabricated to extract more money. MAS can't help directly with offshore entities, correct. Your best bet is to report them to international scam watchdogs like the Internet Complaint Center (IC3) in the US or equivalent bodies in major financial hubs. Keep every email, screenshot, and record of payment. While recovery is unlikely, formal reporting creates a record and can help prevent others from falling prey.

Grace Tan · Singapore, Singaporeanswered 25d ago
3

Yeah, that fee sounds like pure BS. 'Reconciliation' for whom? It's not your job to balance their books. And if they're asking for a 'tax clearance fee' too? Double red flag. These outfits prey on people who don't understand the financial markets or regulations. Honestly, don't expect to get your money back. The only positive thing here is you stopped before it got even worse. My advice: if a broker has flashy ads and promises huge returns, run the other way. Especially if they're not regulated by the CFTC or your local authority.

Noah MacDonald · Halifax, Canadaanswered 25d ago
5

This is a common con. Unregulated brokers will invent any excuse to keep your money. That 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a new one for me, but it fits the pattern. Remember OptionStarsGlobal? Similar story. They demand fees, taxes, etc. My advice? Stop communicating with them immediately. Do not send any more money. Report them to organizations like the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) here in SA, even if they're offshore. It might not recover funds, but it flags them.

Sipho Khumalo · Johannesburg, South Africaanswered 25d ago
6

This is unfortunately a very common scam, especially in the CFD and forex space. An unregulated broker like FXChoice often operates this way. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fabricated charge designed to extract more money before they simply disappear. You should *never* have to pay a fee to reconcile your own profits for withdrawal. Check if they are FCA registered -- if not, stay away. The best advice is to freeze all communication, do not send more funds, and consider reporting them to the AFM, though direct recovery is unlikely.

Noah van Dijk · Groningen, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
3

Ugh, another one. 'Profit and loss reconciliation fee.' Seriously? Sounds completely made up. They probably just invented it because you asked for your money back. If they were legitimate, they'd be regulated by BaFin or another serious entity. You're likely dealing with pure scammers. Don't pay it. Just walk away. Maybe try reporting them to consumer protection agencies, but frankly, getting money back from these fly-by-night operations is a long shot. They just keep inventing fees.

Levi Meijer · Nijmegen, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
4

Yes, this is exactly the scam. I lost £10k to a firm doing the same thing a few years ago. They invented a 'tax liability' first, then a 'transfer fee'. Never heard of a 'P&L reconciliation fee' from a broker. It's total nonsense. My wife told me to just report it and forget it. Tried reporting to the FCA, but they couldn't do much as the broker was offshore. Don't send them anything else. Block them. It saved me from sending them more cash. Just accept it as a very expensive lesson.

Oliver Taylor · Sheffield, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
5

I've been there. They told me I owed an 'international transfer tax' after I tried to withdraw. Then it was a 'compliance bond.' It's always something. This FXChoice broker sounds like a scam artist. They are not regulated by the FCA, which is a huge red flag. My broker even sent me a fake government letterhead! I ended up losing about $15,000. I reported them to Action Fraud here in the UK but honestly, they didn't get my money back. Just block them and don't send more money.

Julia Meijer · Amsterdam, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
7

FXChoice is known for these tactics. This 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fabrication. Legitimate brokers do not charge fees for internal reconciliation processes to release client funds. They might have regulatory reporting requirements, but those are usually included in the account structure or stated upfront. Check the regulatory status of any broker with the relevant authority (like the FCA for the UK/EU or ASIC for Australia) *before* you deposit funds. If they're not listed or are blacklisted, avoid them entirely. Sadly, recovering funds from such operations is extremely difficult.

Emma Laurent · Bordeaux, Franceanswered 25d ago
3

They are scammers, pure and simple. That fee is completely fabricated. My cousin lost a lot of money to a similar broker about a year ago. They kept asking for 'administrative fees' then 'legal fees'. She tried reporting it to the police here in Ras Al Khaimah, but with the broker being offshore, there wasn't much they could do. Just don't send them any more money. It's the only way to stop the bleeding. Learn from this and be super careful next time.

Sara Al Mansoori · Ras Al Khaimah, UAEanswered 25d ago
6

This is a classic scam playbook. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is a fictitious charge designed to extract more funds from you. Reputable brokers, regulated by bodies like the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) or the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), do not operate this way. They have clear fee structures. For any forex or CFD broker, always verify their registration and regulatory standing on the relevant authority's website *before* depositing funds. This is your first line of defense against scams.

Michael Khumalo · Pretoria, South Africaanswered 25d ago
4

Oh no, this is absolutely a scam tactic. I lost a fair bit to a broker that kept inventing fees – a 'compliance fee,' a 'transfer release fee.' They sent me official-looking invoices too! It’s designed to make you give up or pay more. Don't send them another penny. FXChoice is not regulated by the FCA, which is a major warning sign. You can report them to Action Fraud in the UK, but honestly, getting the money back is unlikely. The best you can do is cut your losses and warn others.

Rachel Hall · Liverpool, United Kingdomanswered 25d ago
5

This sounds exactly like the 'advance fee' scam structure. The 'profit and loss reconciliation fee' is entirely made up. They invent these charges to delay and defraud you. No legitimate broker, especially one regulated by a body like the AFM or FCA, would do this. They rely on the fact that recovering funds from offshore entities is incredibly difficult. My advice: stop communicating, do not send more money, and file reports with consumer protection agencies and law enforcement, even if recovery seems unlikely.

Saar de Boer · Rotterdam, Netherlandsanswered 25d ago
6

Hey Olivia, so sorry you're going through this. Yes, that "profit and loss reconciliation fee" sounds EXACTLY like a classic advance-fee scam. These unregulated brokers don't have real regulators to report to, and that invoice they sent? Probably digitally generated. They prey on people's desire for big returns and then invent fees to keep you hooked.

FXChoice is known in many online forums to be a scam operation. They are not regulated by any reputable authority like the FCA, CFTC, or even ASIC here in Australia. Your intuition is spot on – this is a common tactic. Don't send them any more money. Ever.

Your best bet is to report this to the relevant financial authorities in your jurisdiction. The MAS in Singapore might not be able to recover your funds directly if FXChoice is truly offshore and unregistered, but they can investigate and issue warnings, which helps others. Also, check if there's an Australian agency that handles international scam reports and report it there too. Sometimes filing a report with your local police (fraud division) can also put pressure on them.

Olivia Nguyen · Canberra, Australiaanswered 25d ago
5

Ugh, Olivia, i feel your pain. This is spot on for what happened to me last year with OptionStarsGlobal. They hit me with the exact same story – reconciliation fees, tax fees, withdrawal fees… it never ends. I ended up wired about $15k back to my parents before I realized it was a total con.

They even sent me official-looking emails and documents. Made me doubt myself for months, thinking maybe I misunderstood something. It’s sickening how good they are at making you feel like it's your fault or you just need to pay one more thing.

Seriously, just stop sending them money. Pull everything you can off any account associated with them if you can still access it (though they probably won't let you much longer).

I learned the hard way. The only thing you can really do now is try to report them. Maybe your bank can help dispute charges if you used a credit card, but for wire transfers it's near impossible. I just filed with IC3, the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center. It's a long shot, but it's something.

Adam Martin · Nice, Franceanswered 25d ago
7

This is a textbook advance-fee scam that's been around for years, just with different broker names. FXChoice is unfortunately on a lot of watchlists for this exact behavior. They lure people in with promises of high returns, and once you want to take your money out, they invent all sorts of bogus fees.

Think about it: legitimate brokers don't ask for "profit reconciliation" fees. Their profits and losses are part of their internal accounting and regulatory reporting, which they handle themselves. They wouldn't ask *you* to pay a fee to fix their books. The invoice is just a prop.

A key red flag to remember for the future is: never pay fees to withdraw funds from an investment platform. If they ask for money upfront to unlock your own money, it's a scam. Report them to the MAS in Singapore. Also, check if the platform claims to be regulated anywhere. If they say they are regulated by the FCA (UK), CFTC (USA), BaFin (Germany), or ASIC (Australia), you can go to those regulatory bodies' websites and see if the company is actually registered. If they aren't, that's a huge warning sign.

Samantha Jones · Phoenix, USAanswered 25d ago
5

Olivia, it sounds like you've walked straight into a common scam. The "profit and loss reconciliation fee" is a phantom charge invented by fraudulent brokers to extort more money from victims before they can access their supposed earnings. FXChoice, by reports I've seen, does not hold legitimate licenses from financial authorities like the FCA or ASIC, which is a major concern. They operate in a regulatory grey area, making it difficult for authorities like the MAS to intervene directly in fund recovery.

These scammers want you to believe there's a legitimate accounting or regulatory hurdle you need to clear by paying them. It's designed to sound official and complex, playing on your lack of knowledge about financial markets. They might even show you fabricated statements or regulatory documents to back up their claims.

My advice: Never send them another cent. Your savings are likely gone, unfortunately. The best course of action is to file a report immediately with MAS in Singapore. Also, report them to the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) via their Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3). Even if recovery is unlikely, reporting helps these agencies track scam networks and warn others. Keep all correspondence, invoices, and transaction records; they are crucial for any investigation, even if it's just to add to the case file against them.

Mia Petit · Nantes, Franceanswered 25d ago

Your answer

You'll be asked to sign in to post.